Saturday, June 8, 2024

What If Harry Potter Was In Slytherin

Don't Miss

Perk: Many Slytherin Come From Wealthy Families

What If Harry Potter Was Sorted Into Slytherin? Books 1-7 Covered

House Slytherin honors pureblood wizard ideals. As a result, many Slytherin students are wealthy, having long histories in the Wizarding World. Examples include the Malfoys, the Blacks, and the Greengrasses. Naturally, this wealth comes with added influence and a social circle that may give them advantages both as students and as adults. Its a pretty closed circle but one that works well for the children of wizarding aristocracy.

What If Voldemort Had Turned Gryffindor’s Sword Into A Horcrux

Lord Voldemort took pride in having his Horcruxes be items of significance or meaning. He steals Helga Hufflepuff’s cup from a woman named Hepzibah Smith, is able to acquire Salazar Slytherin’s old locket and also persuades Rowena Ravenclaw’s daughter into giving up her mother’s old diadem.

RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Characters Who Were Forgotten As The Movies Went On

Chances are he’d of loved to make Godric Gryffindor’s sword another one of his soul-carriers – and that would probably have been bad news for Harry Potter. The sword is virtually indestructible and Fiendfyre, the tricky spell that kills Crabbe, may have been too dangerous a method to use. It also would have been nearly impossible to destroy items such as the locket, Tom Riddle’s old school diary and Nagini.

Reasons Why Harry Potter Wasnt In Slytherin

Ultimately, Harry got sorted into Gryffindor alongside Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, creating an unbreakable bond between the three.

One of the most quoted scenes to prove Harry could not have been placed in Slytherin happens during the Chamber of Secrets when facing Tom Riddle and the basilisk.

Hes able to withdraw Gryffindors sword from the Sorting Hat, ultimately killing the basilisk and Voldemorts soul encapsulated in the diary.

According to Dumbledore, only a true Gryffindor was worthy of summoning the sword in a dire situation. Besides, his dads families side connected him to Godric Gryffindor himself!

Knowing this, there are also 5 reasons why Harrys place wasnt in the snake house:

Read Also: How Old Is Dumbledore

Harsh Reality: Not Every Slytherin Is Deserving Of Their Post

Earning a position of power isnt everything and some Slytherin graduates dont particularly honor the houses name. The best example is Dolores Umbridge. Harrys Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher in his fifth year, Dolores is easily the most hated character in the series, surpassing even Voldemort. Her thirst for power is so great she attaches herself to anyone who may provide her with an advantage.

What makes her more unlikable is her absolute inadequacy for her post and the dismissiveness she shows toward both her students and colleagues. Even her former Head of House, Horace Slughorn, greatly dislikes her. Her abuses of power give Slytherin a worse name and attitude after she creates the Inquisitorial Squad, recruiting students like Draco Malfoy.

Harry Potter’s Relationship With Severus Snape May Have Changed

What If Harry Potter Were Placed in Slytherin?

Harry Potter would always be terrified of Severus Snape: he is a formidable character and his own Slytherin students fear him. But as one of his own students, Harry may have had a far closer relationship with Snape, not least because being Sorted into Slytherin would challenge the Professor’s belief that Harry is “just like his father.” In light of his more favorable treatment, Harry may have excelled in Potions long before he came into possession of Snape’s textbook because he would have had training from the man himself.

Would he have learned of the truth of his mission prior to Professor Snape’s death? Probably not, because Dumbledore’s agenda with Harry was always to keep him in the dark as much as possible, but the two would probably have enjoyed a less frosty relationship. That might also have impacted how much time and effort Harry spent assuming that Snape was the root of all evil and ignoring other helpful hints.

It’s still unlikely that Harry’s relationship with Lord Voldemort would have changed, however, because the Dark Lord was driven too much by his fear of the prophecy. While he attempted to recruit Lily and James Potter, their son still needed to be destroyed for Voldemort to thrive.

Related: Why The Number 7 Appears Everywhere In Harry Potter

Read Also: What Is Hermione’s Middle Name

Video Result For Slytherin Harry Potter Book Set

LEGO Harry Potter Hogwarts Moment: Gryffindor,…
LEGO Harry Potter Potions Class Review – Hogwarts…
Harry Potter Hogwarts Library Book Set Review!
LEGO Harry Potter 2021 Herbology Class Hogwarts Moment…
lego showcase: Harry Potter slytherin book classroom…
HARRY POTTER books/ Children’s fiction books/…
LEGO Harry Potter Hogwarts Moment Classes Book…
LEGO Harry Potter 2021 Hogwarts Moment Book Sets…
Harry Potter Collection!
My 1st Unboxing: Harry Potter Hogwarts Trunk Set
LEGO Harry Potter Hogwarts Icons Collection -…
My HUGE Harry Potter Collection | Slytherin Edition
Harry Potter Hardcover Box Set 1-7!!! Unboxing!!
LEGO Harry Potter Hogwarts Potions Classroom |…
Building the ENTIRE Harry Potter Hogwarts Icons LEGO…
Harry Potter Horcrux Locket & Sticker Book Set
Harry Potter – Hogwarts Houses Metallic Book Gift Sets
Shopping for Harry Potter Merchandise at…
Harry Potter – Winter At Hogwarts: A Magical Colouring…
My Harry Potter Book Collection
I Got The LEGO Harry Potter 2021 Hogwarts Gryffindor…
Close Look: Slytherin House Edition Of Harry Potter…
LEGO Harry Potter Charms Class – Hogwarts Moment…
LEGO Hogwarts Icons Review & Placement BEST HARRY…
The Harry Potter Collection | Juniper Books



What If Lord Voldemort Chose Neville Longbottom

Harry Potter only became the Chosen One because Lord Voldemort himself picked the boy as the one he thought would become his greatest enemy. The prophecy created by Sybill Trelawney could also have referred to Neville Longbottom who, like Harry, was born in the month of July and whose parents had twice thwarted the Dark Lord.

Yet even if Voldemort had earmarked Neville as the greater threat, the future Hogwarts Herbology teacher would most likely have remained safe. His parents, Frank and Alice Longbottom, wouldn’t have chosen a menace like Peter Pettigrew as their Secret Keeper, hence it being likely that Neville would have been hidden away successfully and the Fidelius Charm would have remained intact.

Also Check: Who Plays Voldemort In Harry Potter 7

His Relationship With The Entire Weasley Family Would Be Almost Nonexistent

Because of his potentially unstable friendship with Ron, Harry might not have had as many opportunities to visit the Weasley family or get close to them. The Weasleys are practically Harry’s second family, and without their support, he would have missed out on Molly’s Christmas sweaters, flying Arthur’s car, getting the Marauder’s map from Fred and George, and spending time with Ginny and the rest of the family during holidays. Harry’s friendship with Ron gave him more than one friend. It gave him a family.

How Harry Got Sorted Into Gryffindor

Harry Potter: What Would Happen If Harry Was A Slytherin

Theres an entire scene dedicated to the moment Harry had the Sorting Hat debating whether he should belong in Slytherin.

Hmm, said a small voice in his ear. Difficult. Very difficult. Plenty of courage, I see. Not a bad mind either. Theres talent, oh my goodness, yes and a nice thirst to prove yourself, now thats interesting. So where shall I put you?

Harry gripped the edges of the stool and thought, Not Slytherin, not Slytherin.

Not Slytherin, eh? said the small voice. Are you sure? You could be great, you know, its all here in your head, and Slytherin will help you on the way to greatness, no doubt about that no? Well, if youre sure better be GRYFFINDOR!

Harry Potter and The Philosophers Stone

However, theres an interesting distinction to make here.

He begged the Sorting Hat to not be placed in Slytherin, rather than asking to go to Gryffindor. He had already heard terrible things from Hagrid and Ron, especially during his first train ride to Hogwarts where he founds out that Voldemort was a notorious Slytherin:

What house are your brothers in? asked Harry.

Gryffindor, said Ron. Gloom seemed to be settling on him again. Mom and Dad were in it, too. I dont know what theyll say if Im not. I dont suppose Ravenclaw would be too bad, but imagine if they put me in Slytherin.

Thats the house Vol-, I mean, You-Know-Who was in?

Yeah, said Ron. He flopped back into his seat, looking depressed.

Harry Potter and The Philosophers Stone

You May Like: What Is The Longest Harry Potter Book

Did Draco Kiss Hermione

One day, Draco decides to erase Hermiones memories. During the Battle of Hogwarts, Hermione and Draco reunite on the room of requirement. Thats a symbolic place for them cause thats where they exchanged their first kiss, thats why Hermione recovers her memories but its too late since shes already with Ron.

He’d Realize Not All Slytherins Are Evil

Going through this existential crisis might make Harry consider why he was sorted into Slytherin after all and why not all of his Slytherin friends are complete jerks like he imagined they would be. Getting to know some Slytherin students better and truly becoming good friends with them wouldn’t only change Harry’s perspective of his house, but it would help him see useful characteristics within himself and his new friends that would help him through his journey.

Recommended Reading: Harry Potter Movies Hulu

Ambition Doesnt Always Mean Seeking Power When Youre A Slytherin

Slytherins have a reputation for their ambition being rooted in seeking as much power and influence as possible. You can understand why, when former students included witches and wizards like Lucius Malfoy, Dolores Umbridge and the one who was after control of the entire wizarding world Lord Voldemort. Nevertheless, there are those whose ambition manifests itself in a different way. Scorpius Malfoy was one such Slytherin. His ambitions were smaller and lot of his were rooted in doing the best he could academically and expanding his magical knowledge. Who can forget just how thrilled he was to come across Hermione Grangers very impressive book collection? He demonstrated that not all Slytherins are driven by the same thing and proved that just because his goals appeared to be smaller, it didnt make them any less worthy or important.

Magical Abilities And Skills

Harry Potter: 10 Times Harry Behaved Like A True Slytherin
It matters, because being able to talk to snakes was what Salazar Slytherin was famous for. Thats why the symbol of Slytherin House is a serpent.
  • Wandlore/Wandmaking: Slytherin created his own wand of snakewood and basilisk horn. He also taught it the unique ability to “sleep” when instructed.
  • Basilisk breeding: Slytherin managed to breed a basilisk and kept it alive in the Chamber of Secrets for over one thousand years, surpassing its average nine-hundred year lifespan.
  • Charms: With the combined abilities of the other founders, he helped to bewitch the Sorting Hat into a sentient and talking magical object with personality, to sort students well after their lifetime. He could also produce at least a non-corporeal Patronus.

Read Also: Which Weasley Brother Dies

Are Phones Allowed At Hogwarts

With no electricity, wizards cant use phones, computers, and more like Muggles do, and the reason for the lack of electricity is because magic interferes with it.

How do wizards poop? J.K. Rowling has revealed that before wizards used modern plumbing, they just pooped where they stood and used magic to get rid of it. if wizards just vanish the poop away why do they have toilets at hogwarts??

Does Muggle technology work at Hogwarts?

Most Muggle electronics including computers, radar, and bugging devices did not work in Hogwartss magical environment. Muggle usage of electricity in their technology was part of the curriculum of the Muggle Studies class at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry.

Dont forget to share this post

What If Hermione Granger Didn’t Exist

Harry Potter is the focal point of the entire franchise, with the Boy Who Lived often joined in his adventures by close friends Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. Yet while Harry and Ron are capable wizards, Hermione is a class above with her intelligence and logic often setting the trio in good stead.

Without Hermione, Harry and Ron would most likely have perished in the Sorcerer’s Stone. Likewise in the Chamber of Secrets. In the Prisoner of Azkaban, it’s also left to her to save the day when Sirius Black looks likely to be imprisoned. And so on. Without Hermione, there’s a genuine chance Harry would never have got anywhere near defeating Lord Voldemort.

Don’t Miss: Protego Meaning Harry Potter

What If Remus Lupin Hadn’t Transformed

Don’t get us wrong we absolutely love Remus Lupin but we can’t quite forgive him for transforming into a werewolf at the most crucial time during the Prisoner of Azkaban book and movie. Just as it looks like Sirius Black will be a free man, and Peter Pettigrew will be subjected to a spell in Azkaban himself, Lupin’s sudden change allows the latter to escape and reunite with Voldemort once again.

Had that not happened, Harry would likely have moved out of Number 4 Private Drive and instead lived with Sirius. But because Pettigrew escaped, the Boy Who Lived’s godfather was unable to clear his name and would ultimately spend the rest of his days with a price on his head.

What If Lord Voldemort Won

What If Harry Potter Were Placed in Slytherin?

The biggest what-if of them all. What if Lord Voldemort had defeated Harry Potter at the Battle of Hogwarts? What if he’d been able to kill the Boy Who Lived rather than the other way round?

Well, put simply, there most likely wouldn’t have been any muggles left. Voldemort wanted to take over their world which probably would have involved mass murder. Similarly, anybody loyal to Harry would have probably been killed and it seems feasible that Hogwarts would have been turned into an institution where the dark arts are taught. Certainly, the world would have been a grim place had Harry not reigned supreme.

Recommended Reading: When Does Dumbledore Die

What If Harry Had Been Sorted Into Slytherin

Prior to setting foot in Hogwarts, Harrys perception of Slytherin was tainted by his interactions with Hagrid, Draco, and Ron. These interactions made Harry predisposed to dislike Slytherin. However, consider an alternative timeline where Harry had been Sorted into Slytherin. How drastically would this have changed the series?

Its important to note that Harry is an innately empathetic person. We first learn this at the zoo in Sorcerers Stone. Harry concludes that being stuck in a glass tank was worse than having a cupboard as a bedroom . In Chamber of Secrets, Harry tells Dobby that his plight as a house-elf makes the Dursleys sound almost human . In Deathly Hallows, Griphook notes that Harrys empathy toward others makes him an unusual wizard . This character trait would have changed readers attitudes toward Slytherin by presenting them with a likable character from that House. The juxtaposition between Harrys personality and the stereotypes the students from the other Houses held about Slytherin would have enriched the series.

Dont forget! Tickets to MuggleNet Live! 2017: Nineteen Years Later are still available for purchase, and we would LOVE to meet you in Orlando for an amazing Potter fandom experience! Check out our website for details and then get your ticket to have a private, magical evening with MuggleNet and the awesome talent from the Potter films!


What If The Potters Had Stuck With Sirius Black

James and Lily Potter are both murdered by Lord Voldemort after their Secret Keeper, old friend Peter Pettigrew, betrayed them by revealing their whereabouts to the villain. Pettigrew wasn’t initially meant to hold the mantle, however, with Sirius Black previously the only person who knew where they were hiding.

It seems feasible that, had the Potters stuck with Black rather than change things at the last minute, they would have survived but this may not have been for the best. Without them dying, Harry Potter may never have had the guts to take on the Dark Lord. And without Potter as the Chosen One, the wizarding community may have suffered as a result.

Also Check: Who Played Lupin In Harry Potter

Harry Takes Unnecessary Risks

Gryffindors are known for constantly wanting to prove themselves in front of their peers.

From trying to hunt Sirius Black by himself, entering the Chambers of Secrets to save Ginny, using the flying car with Ron to arrive at Hogwarts and many other crazy feats, he didnt hesitate twice in risking his life if he thought it was necessary.

The fact that he played Quidditch is another sign of his risky behaviour flying on a broom isnt exactly a safe activity!

While Slytherins are not known for their cautious attitudes, they tend to think twice about getting involved in a complex scenario. Thats why so many Slytherin students chose not to fight at the Battle of Hogwarts and instead some returned with Professor Slughorn with reinforcements.

Why Is Hermione Not In Ravenclaw

Which Harry Potter Slytherin Are You, Based On Your Zodiac

Originally Answered: Why wasnt Hermione in Ravenclaw? Hermione wasnt in Ravenclaw because she valued bravery over intelligence and curiosity. She says so herself many times. One of the first things she says to Ron and Harry is Do either of you know what house youll be in?

Can protego stop a bullet? A single bullet? Probably yes. A Protego charm can shield the user from kinetic attacks, as demonstrated by Dumbledore using it to block glass shards and Umbridge blocking a centaurs arrow.

Would wizards use the Internet? As it is primarily used by Muggles, few witches and wizards used the Internet, and those who did use it tended to do so with a slightly condescending curiosity, or in order to do research on Muggle Studies. Hogwarts students were allowed to use the Internet as research during that lesson.

What was Voldemorts weapon? Dumbledore tells Harry at the end of Order of the Phoenix that this weapon Voldemort was seeking was the knowledge of how to destroy you . Since Harry kept beating Voldemort, Voldemort decided that he needed to hear the prophecy in its entirety.

Read Also: How Did Harry Potter Come Back To Life

More articles

Popular Articles