He Willingly Readied Harry To Die ‘at The Correct Time’
Of all the heinous things that Dumbledore has done, his most villainous is that he knew from the start that Harry would have to die in order to defeat Voldemort – and he set him up for it. Some of his actions have even been theorized to be manipulating him from the start into a hero-worship of Dumbledore strong enough to sacrifice himself: his exile from the wizarding world, his triumphant and love-filled homecoming, years of being praised and supported by Dumbledore and finding only success, the sudden ignoring, the apologies and the pleas for help – all of it may have been part of an evil master plan leading to his death.
It may be that Dumbledore felt that this was the only way to take down Voldemort once and for all, but in the end, all villains have reasons for their plans, and justifications for their actions. Dumbledore, it seems, was no different in plotting the death of a child.
What Did Voldemort Think Of His Mother
Voldemort looked upon his mother’s family with disgust, and certainly did not care for his uncle. … As she died just after Tom had left her womb, he can’t have got an impression of her. Dumbledore says he despised her for giving in to death after all Voldemort had to accept that the magic blood came from her.
Dumbledore Was Just As Bad If Not Worse Than Voldemort
List RulesVote up the clearest evidence of Dumbledore’s malevolence.
Throughout the Harry Potter series, Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore acts as a benevolent force who guides Harry and his friends through adventures both large and small. However, when you look at disturbing facts about Dumbledore, its clear he’s irresponsible at best, and legitimately evil at worst.
One can make the case about Dumbledore’s depravity surpassing Voldemort’s. After all, both wizards needed Harry to die for their plans to work, but only Dumbledore hides his true intentions from the Boy Who Lived.
Readers are rightfully wary about many terrible things in the Wizarding World and the Harry Potter movies: the mistreatment of house-elves the existence of a restrictive sorting system separating students into houses and Dumbledores entire approach to life.
Also Check: Who Gives Harry Potter The Nimbus 2000
He Handled Harrys Pseudo
Not only did he lie to Harry he actively kept him in the dark when Harry might have been starting to catch on because he was literally being possessed by Lord Voldemort. Well, kind of. Voldemort was edging his way into Harrys head and pretty much making him crazy. He was influencing Harrys emotions to be more like his own, making him angry and spiteful, turning his entire world dark and how did Dumbledore handle this? By ignoring Harry and letting him spiral because he was worried Voldemort would try and get to him through Harry.
This was seriously selfish AF. Dumbledore might try and say he had Harrys best intentions at heart, but considering how broken and angsty Harry was in book five, Im not convinced.
Death Eaters And Enemies
Bellatrix Lestrange, a notorious Death Eater
Bellatrix Lestrange was a Death Eater who fought in both Wizarding Wars. She was fanatically loyal to Lord Voldemort and so, although acknowledging Dumbledore as a very powerful wizard, considered her master as the superior being. Bellatrix was among the few people who knew of the plan to assassinate Dumbledore, and that Draco Malfoy had been assigned the task of murdering him. She participated in the Battle of the Astronomy Tower, and reacted to Dumbledore’s death with utter glee. Bellatrix did not live to discover that her initial suspicions of Snape’s loyalty had been correct, dying during a ferocious duel with Molly Weasley. Dumbledore recognised Bellatrix as an incredibly dangerous and sadistic Death Eater, commenting to Severus Snape that, given the choice, he would prefer to die a quick and clean death rather than fall prey to Bellatrix who tended to “play with her food”.
Bellatrix also killed many of Dumbledore’s friends, such as Sirius Black, Dobby the house-elf, and Nymphadora Tonks.
- Dumbledore: “Draco, years ago, I knew a boy who made all the wrong choices. Please, let me help you.”
- Draco Malfoy: “I don’t want your help! Don’t you understand? I have to do this… I have to kill you… otherwise… he’s going to kill me…”
- Dumbledore and Draco Malfoy, when Draco attempts to kill Dumbledore
Don’t Miss: Why Does Voldemort Look Like That
Was It All In His Head
There’s a popular fan theory that everything that happened to Harry Potter outside of Privet Drive was a mental machination of his young, abused mind, and Deathly Hallows did little to dispel that theory. In fact, while at the heavenly version of King’s Cross Station, Harry asked Dumbledore if it was all in his mind and his headmaster told him that it was, but that didn’t make it any less real.
So, was the entirety of the Harry Potter universe fiction, coming from the imagination of a desperate boy who lived under the stairs and who wished for something more? Very possibly so.
Why Harry Potter Movies Changed Dumbledore’s Death
The Harry Potter movies made some changes to the biggest scenes from the books, including Dumbledore’s death and actually made it worse.
Although the Harry Potter movie series did a good job in adapting J.K. Rowlings Wizarding World to the big screen, it had to either omit or change many scenes to better fit the format and also for dramatic purposes. Such is the case of the death of Albus Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, which was changed in ways that fans werent totally on board with and that actually hurt the scene.
Readers around the world were introduced to the Wizarding World in 1997, when Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone was published. The book was followed by six more, telling the story of the boy who lived and his battle against the darkest wizard of all: Lord Voldemort. The books were later adapted into eight movies , bringing the world of Harry Potter to a new audience. As it happens with every cinematic adaptation of a book, many characters, scenes, and events were left out of the movies, and some others were changed for different reasons.
Related: Harry Potter Movies Ruined Fred Weasley’s Death
One of the most emotional moments in the Harry Potter series is Dumbledores death. The beloved Hogwarts headmaster and the one wizard Voldemort was afraid of met his fate in the sixth book, but his death in the movie was very different to the one in the source material, and it actually hurt the original scene.
Recommended Reading: How Long Would It Take To Watch Every Harry Potter Movie
He Left The School Despite His Incredible Power
It seemed, for many of the early books, that whenever Harry was about to go and take down the big bad, Dumbledore wasn’t there. Sometimes, he was mysteriously called away, and other times he was arguably ‘forced out’, but given the sheer power Dumbledore was said to hold, the decision to go seems careless at best.
When Umbridge took over, she was unable to get into the office – and it’s impossible to Apparate on Hogwarts grounds. So Dumbledore’s decisions to simply leave , rather than stand his ground against weaker witches and wizards, seems almost cowardly.
This Answer Is One Giant Spoiler And Most Spoilers Are There In The Open Sorry There’s No Way To Do It Without Them
Dumbledore’s Death was pre-arranged by Dumbledore and Snape back in The Half-Blood Prince :
Snape had to kill Dumbledore. Firstly, because it was an act of mercy for Dumbledore, as he was already dying, first from the curse he received when he put on the Gaunt ring, and second when he drank the potion from the cave with the locket horcrux. That’s what Dumbledore means when he says “Severus. Please.”.
Snape also had to kill Dumbledore to remain a trusted Death Eater, and Voldemort’s right hand. He needed to be a double agent in Voldemort’s ranks in order to be able to help Harry & Co on their quest, such as when he sent his doe Patronus to the lake where he hid the sword of Godric Gryffindor.
As to how Snape became a double agent – it was after Voldemort had become determined to kill Harry as an infant, thus endangering his mother, Lily, whom Snape love since they were children.
Snape begged Dumbledore to protect Lily however, Lily still died. Snape continued to serve Dumbledore as a double agent to honour her memory , which was living in her son
Don’t Miss: Which Twin Dies In Harry Potter
Yes Dumbledore Did Ask Snape To Kill Him So Draco Wouldnt
Dumbledore did indeed ask Snape to kill him, so that Draco wouldnt either succeed and maim his own soul, or more likely fail and be killed by the Dark Lord for his almost inevitable failure.
All the same, try. I am concerned less for myself than for accidental victims of whatever schemes might occur to the boy. Ultimately, of course, there is only one thing to be done if we are to save him from Lord Voldemorts wrath.
Snape raised his eyebrows and his tone was sardonic as he asked, Are you intending to let him kill you?
Certainly not. You must kill me. – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33
Dumbledore didnt want Draco to do it and harm his soul, but he also didnt want to die at the hands of someone who would prolong his death and make it more painful. He preferred that Snape kill him quickly, and since it was done as an act of mercy, Snapes soul would remain intact.
Its clear that Dumbledore did both ask and expect Snape to kill him, and this was always his plan.
After you have killed me, Severus
You refuse to tell me everything, yet you expect that small service of me! snarled Snape, and real anger flared in the thin face now. – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33
So yes, Dumbledore did indeed ask Snape to kill him to spare Draco the Dark Lords wrath or a maimed soul because of Dracos own attempts to kill Dumbledore.
He Also May Have Been Too Weak To Do Much Different
Dumbledore was quite weak after having drank the potion in the Horcrux bowl. Harry had to Apparate him back, and he was so weak at that point, hed collapsed on the ground.
Ive been better, said Dumbledore weakly, though the corners of his mouth twitched. That potion was no health drink
And to Harrys horror, Dumbledore sank on to the ground. – Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Chapter 27
He did actively choose not to fight that being when hed be killed, since hed immobilized Harry so he couldnt help fight, but that may have also been in part because Dumbledore knew he was in no shape to fight himself out of the situation even when Harrys help. He was in bad shape, and he knew dying at some point soon was inevitable, so he probably didnt consider it worth the effort to try fighting, possibly fail, and possibly die in a different way than hed intended and ruining his plan.
He didn’t care
I think there were several different reasons that he chose to die, first, this might be a minor one and possibly nonexistent but he was greedy and chose to die to rid himself of the ever worsening world and he was also very very very old so he was probably declining in power and wanted to settle down and have some peace which was seemingly lacking throughout his life and was too prideful to actually die in combat so he made one of his minions kill him so that word would spread that he chose death rather than dying in combat or at the hand of Voldemort.
Recommended Reading: What Was The Punishment For Most Offenses Under Draco’s Code
And What About The Third Brother’s Elder Wand Dumbledore Had That In His Possession Too
Dumbledore acquired the Elder Wand’s powers during a famous duel before the books take place. During his demise, the power of the wand shifts from himself to Draco Malfoy accidentally, and then ultimately to Harry Potter, who defeats Malfoy in a duel.
So with all that knowledge, here’s the theory that’s . The theorist also notes that Dumbledore first met Harry Potter at King’s Cross and that he was ultimately behind/involved in the deaths of Severus Snape and Lord Voldemort.
What Did Dumbledore Say To Snape Before He Died
Severus please These were the last words Dumbledore said to Snape before he used the Avada Kedavra curse and killed the Headmaster of Hogwarts.
In the beginning, we thought the phrase meant, Please, Severus, help me! but the truth was different. The ending of book seven Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows revealed that Dumbledore was dying and that he had arranged that Snape would administer the final kill.
Finally, when the time came for Snape to actually kill Dumbledore he hesitated, regardless of their previous agreement, so Dumbledore had to beg Severus to end his life.
So, the real meaning of the phrase was: Severus, please kill me right now.
Also Check: Harry Potter Draco
Is Dumbledore Really Dead
Readers of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince were dismayed by the apparent death of Albus Dumbledore, Headmaster of Hogwarts, Chief Mugwump of the International Confederation of Wizards, and Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot. He is a crucial character in the Harry Potter books and in the development of Harry Potter himself. The wizard seems to have an unerring instinct for sources of danger, and wisely guides the other characters through perilous situations.
Dumbledore’s death scene on top of the astronomy tower and subsequent funeral did leave many readers wondering if he was actually, in fact, dead. Many readers feel that a wizard with the strength and powers of Dumbledore could not possibly be killed, and may be faking his own death for reasons of his own which would become apparent in the next book, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Much to the disappointment of readers, J.K. Rowling has said that Dumbledore is in fact dead. Since he has mentioned that to the well organized wizard, death is but the next great adventure, perhaps his death is not as awful as readers think it is.
Harry Didnt Really Die
After the Killing Curse hit him, Harry asks Dumbledore if hes dead, and Dumbledore says no.
Then Im dead too?
Ah, said Dumbledore, smiling still more broadly. That is the question, isnt it? On the whole, dear boy, I think not.
They looked at each other, the old man still beaming.
Not? repeated Harry.
Not, said Dumbledore. – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 35
The reason for this, Dumbledore goes on to explain, is that the Dark Lord taking his blood tethered him to life while the Dark Lord lived, since Lilys protection was then inside them both.
He took your blood believing it would strengthen him. He took into his body a tiny part of the enchantment your mother laid upon you when she died for you. His body keeps her sacrifice alive, and while that enchantment survives, so do you and so does Voldemorts one last hope for himself. – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 35
Harrys blood in the Dark Lord tied him to life, so he didnt truly die. He was further helped by being the true master of the Elder Wand. It didnt want to kill its master, so the Killing Curse it cast against him wasnt as powerful as it could have been. It had nothing to do with the Resurrection Stone – that only brings back the shadows of people who are already dead, it doesnt prevent death.
You May Like: What Is The Cure For Boils Harry Potter Hogwarts Mystery
He Plots Muggle Subjugation With His Lover Grindelwald
When Albus is very young, his sister Ariana is attacked by a group of Muggle boys. His father Percival takes revenge and is imprisoned in Azkaban for it. Albus, Ariana, and their brother, Aberforth, are raised by their mother Kendra until Ariana has a magical accident that kills Kendra. After that, it is up to Albus to take charge of his younger siblings. Having been a magical prodigy at Hogwarts, Albus feels stilted and bitter at the turn his life has taken.
When he meets Gellert Grindelwald, the two quickly strike a friendship that eventually turns romantic. Their shared interest in the Deathly Hallows, as well as Albus’s desire to reach his true magical potential, makes him support Gellert’s schemes of Muggle subjugation. He tells himself it will be for the greater good. He may have continued to hold onto that belief if renewed tragedy hadn’t struck the Dumbledore family. When Belfort confronts Albus and Gellert about their plans, a three-way duel starts between them. Ariana is killed by a stray spell, and her death creates a permanent rift between a horrified Albus and his lover.
He Doesn’t Look Into The Trial Of Sirius Black
For many years, Sirius Black is believed to have betrayed the Potters, giving away their secret to Voldemort. In reality, he never receives a trial and is just thrown into Azkaban without a real investigation. Even if Albus was convinced Sirius was guilty, he would have known the trial didn’t happen. It was his duty to ensure it, and he never did.
You May Like: Does Hulu Have Harry Potter Movies