Tuesday, June 25, 2024

Why Are Harry Potter Books Banned

Don't Miss

‘the Things They Carried’ By Tim O’brien

Parents complained of priest who banned Harry Potter books

The Vietnam War may have started more than 60 years ago, but that doesn’t make the war stories of “The Things They Carried” any less relevant for young readers today. It’s not an easy read but that’s the point. Learning about the day-to-day struggles soldiers have to endure is not supposed to be easy. It’s supposed to be uncomfortable. It’s supposed to be vulgar, explicit, and confusing because that’s exactly what soldiers face. The novel provides an unfiltered view of war that vastly contrasted the way people felt about World War II. It represents a pivotal point in history and mirrors the public sentiment of the 70s when people stopped romanticizing war and started critically examining why we go to war and how it affected those who fought. This book presents a much-needed glimpse into the real lives of soldiers, and while it may not be a feel-good read, its a necessary one. Kate Ellsworth

Is Harry Potter Banned By The Catholic Church

The Catholic Church has taken no official position on the books, but various Catholics, including officials of the Roman Curia, the hierarchy, and other official bodies have presented mixed views on the subject.

What countries is Harry Potter banned in? Bulgaria and Greece are some of the countries where the Harry Potter books series has been banned.

What did the pope say about Harry Potter? ROME As a preface to the release of the latest Harry Potter novel this weekend, two letters written by Pope Benedict XVI that are critical of the best-selling series have surfaced, and in them the pope contends that the tales are sacrilegious and dangerous for children.

Is Harry Potter based on the Bible? Others, such as John Killinger, in his book The Life, Death, and Resurrection of Harry Potter, insist that Rowlings story is nothing other than a modern retelling of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, with Harry as the Christ figure.

‘persepolis’ By Marjane Satrapi

When I first read Persepolis in college, I was immediately enchanted with the punk-rock protagonist of the graphic memoir. I never lived through the Islamic Revolution in Iran but to see Satrapi depict how the revolution disrupted individuals, families and communities has always stuck with me. Im very much a supporter of women and girls who like to talk back, as Beyoncé once sang, and who challenge the status quo. Im not sure how anyone can read Persepolis and not be touched by how loving Satrapis family is even when they are fearful for her safety. Satrapi showed us what life was like as a young, rebellious woman growing up in Iran during the 1980s. For those who found a way to survive, they lived life as best they could. And like so many other young women coming-of-age Satrapi had sex and cursed and used drugs. Experimenting is what young people do. Its an insult to her vulnerability that some have tried to ban her book. Mabinty Quarshie

Recommended Reading: What’s The Fifth Harry Potter Movie

‘the Glass Castle’ By Jeannette Walls

I first read “The Glass Castle” on assignment as a rookie reporter in my college town. The memoir had been selected by the university and county library as a summer book. It was an appropriate choice for two institutions little more than 100 miles from Welch, West Virginia, the closest thing the author has to a hometown. Many of the issues Walls faced as a kid are endemic to the area: poverty, substance abuse, violence. She tackled them head-on so much so that her detailed descriptions have been used as fodder to ban the book from school curriculums. That short-sightedness misses how masterfully Walls infuses the truth about her problematic childhood with a sense of pride and perseverance. As a reporter in the Appalachian mountains, I knew kids there and across America were suffering the same social ills . Walls’ writing tells them they shouldnt be ashamed of their circumstances and the decisions of adults around them, and that they dont have to carry the stigma of poverty or abuse. I can think of few more meaningful messages. Save, maybe, the one she inscribed in my copy: Just tell the truth! Kelly

Harry Potter Challenged In Georgia

» What is the most banned book of the decade?

Harry Potter continues to face challenges in public school systems. Most often, this challenges are brought by conservative Christian parents who are concerned that the book contains “witchcraft”, i.e., wizards and witches, magic, and sorcery.

Want to get involved? Heres how:

On April 20, a hearing officer designated by the Gwinnett County Board of Education will hear testimony from the complainant and from school system officials. The hearing will begin at 2:00 p.m. in Hearing Room A at Lawrenceville East .

Any Gwinnett County citizen who wishes to speak on behalf of or in opposition to the challenged books must submit a written request to do so. Requests must be received no later than 48 hours before the hearing. They may be mailed to the Superintendents Office, Gwinnett County Public Schools, 437 Old Peachtree Road, NW, Suwanee, GA 30024-2978, or may be faxed to 678-301-6030.

Incident Details:

You May Like: Dumbledore’s Hand

Is Dumbledore A Jesus

Is Albus Dumbledore a literary icon of Christ? He is not if you think this means he is a stock figure from the Christian back-lot. He is not an allegorical or obvious Jesus. He is a symbol of Christ, though, in that Ms.

Is Harry Potter banned in America? The curses and spells used in the books are actual curses and spells, which when read by a human being risk conjuring evil spirits into the presence of the person reading the text, Reehil added.

Why is Harry Potter banned in some states?

In some parts of the United States and United Kingdom, the Potter books have been banned from being read in school, taken out of libraries, and even burned in public. The most prominent objections to Harry Potter fall into three categories: they promote witchcraft they set bad examples and theyre too dark.

Can Christians watch anime? Any Christian can watch anime. However, many anime shows can be extremely bloody, vulgar, and/or sexually explicit. Exposure to these things can take a Christian to places they should go, lest they risk compromising their relationship with God.

‘1984’ By George Orwell

One of the most thought-provoking and interesting dystopian books I have come across, I read “1984” back in high school when it was assigned reading for my English class. There is simply no other book that can quite frankly show readers what it would be like to live in a society where the freedom to think and make choices for oneself is not allowed. This book sheds light on why it is important for people to express themselves and make choices, and why freedom of expression is important in society. Another important theme that struck my attention was misinformation and disinformation being spread by the ruling party. . As an early career reporter, I strive to make sure that the public knows the truth and the facts. This book is a must-read for any high schooler because it teaches lessons that you wouldnt get from any other book Kochi

Don’t Miss: What Type Of Dog Was Fang From The Harry Potter Movies

Banned Books Week : Harry Potter: The Most Challenged Book Of The 21st Century

Posted 09/26/21 by Jozlyn H

The Wizarding World of Harry Potter

If you asked most people in 1997 if they thought this new, magic-themed childrens novel just published in the UK would become an entire universe, complete with eight movies, a London studio tour experience, a massive amusement park, and more, they probably would have said no. In fact, when Harry Potter and the Sorcerers Stone was first published, many parents and teachers did not want this book in their schools, homes, or libraries. At. All. The book promoted witchcraft, the occult, and anti-family themes just to name a few. It was successfully banned from thousands of places. How could this so familiar, childhood staple, much loved book series, go from ban after ban to world-renowned family favorite?

The first Harry Potter book was published in the United States in 1998 and was immediately challenged. Challenging a book means that someone raised the idea that the book should not be readily available for the public audience. After a challenge is voiced at a school, library or bookstore, that entity may choose to ban the book or dismiss the challenge.

Since its initial publication, the Harry Potter series has been translated into over 79 different languages, the most recent translation being into Scots in 2017. TLCPL has most of the series in French, Spanish, and German. If you want a different language, just ask your local librarian — they can probably get it for you.

‘the Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn’ By Mark Twain

Catholic school bans all Harry Potter books

Because of needed context, I wouldnt read it before The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. But Tom was a fling Huck still holds my hand when I write. I cant remember when I first read them, but English is my second language, and both helped me learn not only how English has changed but also how America has changed. When I met Huck, I heard only the boys voice and saw only what he understood. Upon rereading and realizing what Jim had been saying all along, I entered another universe through the eyes of a Black enslaved man, ripped from his family and fighting through his fear to survive. I never forgot how Twain gave depth to such different voices in Huck. He helped me write and rewrite my own novel. Keep Huck, for its teaching mechanics as well as its wise heart. Elston

Recommended Reading: What Does Stupefy Do

Where Is Harry Potter Banned In The Us

A Catholic school in Nashville, Tennessee has banned the Harry Potter series because a reverend at the school claims the books include both good and evil magic, as well as spells, which, if read by a human can conjure evil spirits, according to the Tennessean. The publication obtained an email from Rev.

Who Has The Power To Ban Books

In accordance with the Pico norm, school authorities may not remove books from the school library just because they disagree with the concepts included in the book, according to Pico. School administrators, on the other hand, have the authority to remove a book from a school library if they believe it is inappropriate for the students at the school.

Also Check: What’s In Wideye Potion

’50 Shades Of Grey’ By El James

In a time in which we consider ourselves forward thinkers, it is shocking to still consider any conversation revolving around sex taboo. “50 Shades” is one of the most well-known and controversial erotica novels, but there are a vast number of authors trying to broach the subject, many worrying their writing is only good behind closed doors. In writing “50 Shades,” James gives those writers a voice those that have been waiting for the right moment to share their deepest, darkest desires with the world. It is necessary to normalize thoughts about sex and not slap tape across our lips to keep from expressing our tastes in the bedroom. Nishka Dhawan

Is Harry Potter Banned

Harry Potter banned by Christian school

As reported by the American Library Association, the Harry Potter series is presently the most questioned series of books in the whole twenty-first century. Book Challenges and Bans continue to be issued across the United States, with the most recent incidence being at a Nashville Catholic school in January 2019.

Also Check: Draco Malfoy Zodiac Sign

Why Are Books Being Banned 2020

In 2020, more than 273 titles were challenged or banned, with a rising number of requests to remove books that confront racism and racial justice, as well as those that conveyed the stories of Black, Indigenous, and other people of color, from the shelves. As has been the case in past years, LGBTQ+-themed entertainment dominated the list.

Harry Potter And The Philosopher’s Stone

In the US these books changed the focus of censorship in schools and libraries. Before 1999, challenges were to do with sex, the human body or inappropriate language. This shifted to focus on the fantasy and glorification of magic and the occult, which confused children and tempted them to try the spells and curses they read about.

There were concerns over the violence and increasingly dark tone of the later books but most of the censorship attempts were for religious reasons. It was also banned in some Christian schools in the UK.

Read Also: What Side Is Harry Potters Scar

Is Harry Potter Haram In Islam

Harry Potter is a series that has its basis deep rooted in magic something that is expressly prohibited to learn and practice in Shariah. It should be kept in mind that in Islam, there is no differentiation or separation in magic no good magic in contrast to dark arts. All magic is prohibited.

Is The Bible A Banned Book

Why Harry Potter Became The Most BANNED Book In America

The Bible is one of the most difficult texts to understand this year. When it comes to book banning, there are no rules or exceptions. A list of the top ten most challenged or banned books of 2015 has been issued by the American Library Association, and among the typical culprits is an unexpected bestseller: the Bible.

Also Check: 3rd Harry Potter Movie

Banning Book Books Should Be Banned

Even though it censors inappropriate material that influences impressionable minds, we should not ban books books because it filters realism and limits our ability for an open mind. It would deprive students of an education about the world around them. Banning books would completely get rid of our freedom of expression and it would restrain our usually infinite imagination. If we allow for books to be banned, it would limit our ability to have imagination and have an open mind about the world around us.

‘to Kill A Mockingbird’ By Harper Lee

When the school board in Biloxi, Mississippi, argued “To Kill a Mockingbird” should be kept out of the classroom in 2017 because it makes people “uncomfortable, they actually nailed the best reason to keep it on the shelves. Everything in the book is uncomfortable, and not because it accurately describes overt racism in sometimes noxious language. Its uncomfortable because it holds up a mirror to our present: the ease with which neighbors will embrace lies and willingly fall in with a mob a legal system working overtime to send a Black man to prison how fear informs our uninformed view of the mentally ill and the brutal dividing line between the poor and the privileged. This is a provocative book, not a perfect one. But the shortcomings of 1930s race, society and language it depicts which so distress critics and made the Biloxi school board so uncomfortable are not failings of the authors words. They are the continued failings of our world. Now is not the time to look away. Patricia Beall

Recommended Reading: How Does George Die In Harry Potter

Tennessee School Bans Harry Potter Books Because The Spells Could Conjure Evil Spirits

Parents of students at St. Edward Catholic School in Nashville will have to pass down their Harry Potter obsession without the help of the school library. The Tennesseanreports that Rev. Dan Reehil, a pastor at the parish school, has ordered that the series be removed from the library in response to a parents inquiry.

The curses and spells used in the books are actual curses and spells which when read by a human being risk conjuring evil spirits into the presence of the person reading the text, Reehil wrote in an email to teachers.

Reehil also explained in the email that although the books represent magic as good and evil, thats just a clever deception, and argued that magic is inherently malevolent. He consulted exorcists in the U.S. and Rome, who advised that the books should be removed from the library.

The Catholic Church doesnt have an official stance on whether Harry Potter is suitable for its members. According tothe Guardian, a Vatican spokesperson in 2003 maintained that the content was in line with Christian morals, but the books have frequently been banned by individual institutions over the course of the last couple of decades.

Do Harry Potter spells actually work, as Reehil suggested? Ask the nearest Potterhead how many times theyve muttered Expecto patronum, Expelliarmus, or another Latin-based incantation to no avail.

Did Jk Rowling Rip Off Lord Of The Rings

harry potter and the order of the phoenix

The quick answer: no, author J.K. Rowling definitely did not copy The Lord of the Rings. The separate works pull from European and Norse mythology, and therefore can sometimes overlap in their story.

Is Harry Potter a copy of Star Wars? Its hard not to acknowledge the similarities between both franchises, but does this mean that Harry Potter is just another Star Wars rip-off? While there may have been some inspiration from a galaxy far, far away, Harry Potter is far from a rip-off.

Is Harry Potter based on mythology? J K Rowlings popular Harry Potter series of books draws immensely from ancient Greek mythology in characterisation, plot, theme, animals or imaginary creatures and various other aspects.

Dont forget to share this post

Recommended Reading: Who Does Harry Potter Marry

Why Are Harry Potter Books Banned In America

In fact, when Harry Potter and the Sorcerers Stone was first published, many parents and teachers did not want this book in their schools, homes, or libraries. The book promoted witchcraft, the occult, and anti-family themes just to name a few. It was successfully banned from thousands of places.

Does Harry Potter believe in God? It is never revealed if the wizarding world believes in any kind of God or supreme being, but they do believe in an afterlife .

Is Harry Potter still censored?

According to the American Library Association, Harry Potter books are now the most challenged books of the entire 21st century. The books continue to be challenged and banned across the United States, the most recent occurrence in a Nashville Catholic school in 2019.

What does the church think of Harry Potter? A Vatican spokesman has defended the Harry Potter books and films, saying they are consistent with Christian morals. The Rev Peter Fleetwood, a member of the Vaticans council for culture, was speaking at the launch of a document warning of the dangers of new age spiritual beliefs to the Catholic faith.

More articles

Popular Articles