Why Did Harry Potter Intentionally Lose The Resurrection Stone In The Forbidden Forest
Just before he is sacrificed to Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest, Harry dropped the Resurrection Stone.
I thought he would come, said Voldemort in his high, clear voice, his eyes on the leaping flames. I expected him to come. Nobody spoke. They seemed as scared as Harry, whose heart was now throwing itself against his ribs as though determined to escape the body he was about to cast aside. He hands were sweating as he pulled off the Invisibility Cloak and stuffed it beneath his robes, with his wand. He did not want to be tempted to fight. I was, it seems . . . mistaken, said Voldemort. You werent. Harry said it as loudly as he could, with all the force he could muster. He did not want to sound afraid. The Resurrection Stone slipped from between his numb fingers, and out of the corner of his eyes he saw his parents, Sirius, and Lupin vanish as he stepped forward into the firelight. At that moment he felt that nobody mattered but Voldemort. It was just the two of them.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 34. The forest again, page 592 of 638
Why did he do that?And Why didn’t he come back and search for it later?
- 6The second I saw that in the movie I thought “Rowling just gave herself a way to continue the story”. Never really noticed it in the book. user2452Jul 24 ’11 at 20:32
- 3Aug 1 ’12 at 6:39
- 9…because you don’t do that and next thing you know you’re walking barefoot to a godforsaken volcano to destroy it…
Unlock This Answer Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
The sorcerer’s stone is not the same thing as the Resurrection stone from the Deathly Hallows. The sorcerer’s stone in the first book was invented by Nicholas Flamel. Flamel used it to keep himself and his wife alive for years and years. Dumbledore, however, feared that Voldemort would take the stone to try and resurrect himself, so he convinced Flamel to let him hide it at Hogwarts.
The resurrection stone, however, had been found by Dumbledore on the cursed ring of Marvolo Gaunt. It appears at the end of Deathly Hallowsin Harry’s snitch that he received in Dumbledore’s will.
At the end of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Harry does not use the stone to resurrect himself or anyone else for that matter. He faces Quirrell and Voldemort, but Quirrell cannot touch him, because of ancient blood magic left in place by Harry’s mother’s sacrifice. After Harry escapes and Quirrell perishes, Dumbledore announces that the sorcerer’s stone will be destroyed.
Yes Actually: Why Did Dumbledore Lie To Harry
Why would Dumbledore be telling porkies in Kings Cross? Why did his former headmaster play the Lily love card again instead of revealing Harrys full house of Hallows? Because, as WippitGuud explains, Dumbledore was protecting Harry: knowing youre the master of the Hallows could make anyone power hungry. Just remember, Dumbledore was happy to lie to Harry for years about his relationship with Voldemort. Case closed.
So, this theory in short: Harry needed to die to defeat Voldemort, but Dumbledore tried to keep Harry in the shade again.
Read Also: Is Lego Harry Potter Backwards Compatible Xbox One
How Harry Potter Survived The Killing Curse In The Deathly Hallows
The question of how Harry Potter survived Voldemort’s Killing Curse in the Forbidden Forest is complex, but it all comes back to Lily Potter.
The matter of how Harry Potter survived Lord Voldemort’s Killing Curse in the Forbidden Forest, at the end of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, can be confusing for even hardcore fans of the books and films.
Harry had a long-standing connection to the Killing Curse. His first encounter with the Avada Kedavra incantation gave him a reputation that would carry on through his time at Hogwarts. However, it was Harry’s later brush with death in the Forbidden Forest during Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows that confused readers and watchers of the series – unsurprisingly, since the explanation involves a complex exchange of spells and Voldemort ultimately being the architect of his own downfall.
Related: Harry Potters Bizarre Dumbledore Is Time-Traveling Ron Theory Explained
Even though the Harry Potter series was full of magic, conflict, and mystery, there was a lot of heart at the center of the story, so it makes sense that something like family and everlasting love would be the driving force behind Harry’s survival and Voldemort’s subsequent defeat. Here’s a breakdown of why Harry survived that night in the Forbidden Forest.
How Did Harry Potter Come Back To Life
The Harry Potter franchise contains many different emotional deaths and one such should have been Harry himself. However, turns out Harry actually comes back to life after he got hit by the Killing curse. This confused many fans since the Killing curse was presented as a piece of magic that allows you to instantly kill your opponents. So, how did Harry avoid death and come back to life?
The truth is Harry never actually died. His mothers protection lived on in Voldemorts blood after he incorporated it in the potion which brought him back to his physical body. This is why Harry got to heaven, but since he could choose to stay alive he managed to come back to the real world.
If you want to know more about this topic which often confuses fans keep reading this article.
Recommended Reading: What’s The Third Harry Potter
After 20 Years Of Movie Magic From The Harry Potter Films Will We Be Seeing The Golden Trio Back In Their Roles Once More
On November 16th 2001, the very first Harry Potter film, Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone was released.
This was the beginning of a wider franchise, inspired by J.K. Rowlings original books, that would go on to span two film series, a stage play, theme parks, merchandise, and more around the world.
How Does The Wizarding World Examine Life After Death
So, you came back, didnt you? said Harry urgently. People can come back, right? As ghosts. They dont have to disappear completely. Well? he added impatiently, when Nick continued to say nothing.Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
It was a heartbreaking moment for Harry . For an instant after Siriuss death, Harry thought he could have his godfather back in another form. But Nearly Headless Nick dashed all hope of Sirius returning as a ghost and revealed that ghosts werent exactly alive. They existed neither here nor there and were only imprints of their former selves. They couldnt move on from Earth because of unfinished business in Nicks case, fear of death and dwelled in old resentments for centuries. Was this really a life worth living?
To us Muggles, magic may seem all-powerful, but as Harry learned in his conversation with Gryffindors house ghost and continued to learn throughout his journey, even magic could never truly bring someone back from the dead.
This lesson was instilled in wizards from childhood. In Dumbledores commentary about The Tale of the Three Brothers in Tales of Beedle the Bard, he noted that Human efforts to evade or overcome death are always doomed to disappointment.
Unfortunately, the tale didnt stop wizards from trying to master death some even reached the point of obsession . In their attempts, several magical methods to lengthen life or remain Earth-bound were discovered but there was always a catch.
You May Like: What Harry Potter House Am I In Test
Why Was Dumbledore Killed
Why did Dumbledore let Snape kill him? He wanted Snape to remain a trusted member of the Death Eaters, as well as to prove Lord Voldemort his loyalty and show him that he hadnt failed. Also, being familiar with the fact Lord Voldemort has ordered Draco Malfoy for killing him, Dumbledore wanted to protect Dracos soul.
Harry Potter Was The Master Of The Elder Wand
One reason that Harry lived after being hit by the Killing Curse in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is his mastery of the Elder Wand. There was a belief that obtaining the Deathly Hallows would grant the finder some sort of immortality. The Deathly Hallows were directly connected to the legend from The Tales of Beedle the Bard. In the tale, the Peverell brothers tricked Death, who in return offered them “gifts” intended to corrupt them and lead to their deaths. The rewards included the Elder Wand, the Resurrection Stone, and the Invisibility Cloak.
Harry notably possessed all three items that comprised the Deathly Hallows when Voldemort tried to kill him the night of the Battle of Hogwarts. He received the Cloak of Invisibility from his father, James, and obtained the Resurrection Stone from Dumbledore after it was hidden in a snitch. While it’s unclear whether there’s any truth to the “Master of Death” being immortal, the Elder Wand will resist causing harm to its master – who, via a roundabout series of events, was Harry. Draco was the previous owner of the Elder Wand, but Harry successfully disarmed him, making Harry the new master even while the Elder Wand was technically in Voldemort’s possession. Harry’s mastery of the Elder Wand explains why Voldemort failed to kill him in their final battle, but there’s also another explanation for why Harry survived the Killing Curse in the Forbidden Forest.
You May Like: When Is The Next Harry Potter Marathon
Mythic Origins Of The Stone
- “Then the second brother, who was an arrogant man, decided that he wanted to humiliate Death still further, and asked for the power to recall others from Death. So Death picked up a stone from the riverbank and gave it to the second brother, and told him that the stone would have the power to bring back the dead.”
- The Tale of the Three Brothers
Death grants Cadmus with the Resurrection Stone
According to the legend recounted by Beedle, the Bard in The Tale of the Three Brothers, Cadmus Peverell, and his two brothers were travelling along a long, winding road at twilight when they came upon a river too deep and rapid to cross. When the brothers conjured a bridge to cross the river, Death appeared before them. Angry that they had found a way to cross the river without dying, Death pretended to offer each brother a gift, hoping that the gift would lead to their downfall. As Cadmus was arrogant, he wanted to further humiliate Death, which led to him asking for the Resurrection Stone. He wished for an item that would enable him to bring back the dead, so Death took a stone from the riverbank and used his abilities to transform it into the Resurrection Stone.
Who Will Be In The Harrypotter Special On Hbo Max
Fans can look forward to seeing Radcliffe, Grint and Watson reflect on their rolesbut their three central characters arent the only ones heading back to Hogwarts. According to that teaser, other returning stars include Helena Bonham Carter, Robbie Coltrane, Ralph Fiennes, Jason Isaacs, Gary Oldman, Imelda Staunton, Tom Felton, James Phelps, Oliver Phelps, Mark Williams, Bonnie Wright, Alfred Enoch, Matthew Lewis, Evanna Lynch and Ian Hart.
After the special was announced, Watson took to Instagram to share throwback photos of herself with Grint and Radcliffe, writing in part, Harry Potter was my home, my family, my world and Hermione my favorite fictional character of all time.
I am proud not just of what we as group contributed as actors to the franchise but also as the children that became young adults that walked that path, she continued. I look at my fellow cast members now and I am just so proud of who everyone has become as people. I am proud we were kind to each other, that we supported one another and that we held up something meaningful.
As for Harry Potter: Hogwarts Tournament of Houses, fans can expect appearances not just from franchise alums like Felton, Simon Fisher-Becker, Shirley Henderson and Luke Youngblood, but also from star superfans Pete Davidson and Jay Leno.
Also Check: Which Harry Potter Character Are You Female
Lily’s Protection In Voldemort’s Blood Saved Harry
When Lord Voldemort rebuilt his physical body in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, he used Harry’s blood. That ingredient would go on to aid in the Dark Lord’s downfall. At first it seemed that the love protection was canceled out when Voldemort used Harry’s blood, since Voldemort was able to touch Harry without experiencing pain – but that wasn’t the case. The protection, first created by Lily, actually lived on through Voldemort when he received a new body. As Dumbledore explained, “His body keeps her sacrifice alive, and while that enchantment survives, so do you.”
When Voldemort hit Harry with the Killing Curse in the forest, it destroyed the Horcrux that resided in Harry, but left Harry himself alive. Since Voldemort was still alive, Lily’s love spell was still in effect. Harry was sent to limbo, where he encountered Dumbledore. He was given a choice to die and finally rest, or return home, and he chose the latter. Nagini remained as Voldemort’s last Horcrux until Neville destroyed her with the Gryffindor’s Sword. With no Horcruxes remaining as Voldemort’s primary defenses, this left the Dark Lord vulnerable.
- Fantastic Beasts 3 Release date: Jul 15, 2022
Did Dumbledore Know Harry Would Survive
Although most fans look at professor Dumbledore as a mentor figure who always wanted the best for Harry, we actually dont know if he knew Harry would survive. His conversation with Snape lets us know that he was aware of the fact that Harry has to die by Voldemorts hand, however, there is no talk about whether Harry would survive his encounter with Voldemort.
The conversation we get throughout the series points to the fact that Dumbledore was ready to sacrifice Harry for the greater good or convince him to surrendering to Voldemort would be the best course of action.
Because the blood sacrifice created the bond between the two and that event only took place during the fourth movie/ book it probably messed up all of the theories Dumbledore had.
This is further complicated by the fact that Harry was a Horcrux and there is very little information regarding Horcruxes. Aside from Nagini, Harry is the only living Horcrux and no one really knows what happens to the host once the part of the soul is destroyed.
Additionally, Harry is different from Nagini as well, since Voldemort planned to create Nagini and that wasnt the case with Harry. The little information that is out there regarding Horcruxes does involve the note that they have to be created willingly.
Don’t Miss: Are The Harry Potter Movies On Amazon Prime
Will There Also Be A Harry Potter Reboot
Along with a Hogwarts letter, many fans have been eagerly awaiting a revival of the fantasy franchise for quite some time. However, it seems the retrospective special is the only project currently in the works. While rumors swirled about a scripted show earlier this year, HBO Max denied having a Harry Potter series in development at the time.
Even if a reboot makes its way to screens someday, its safe to say thered be some casting shakeups. Many of the actors, including Radcliffe, have previously said theyd prefer not to reprise their exact roles in a reboot.
I would probably want to go with Sirius or Lupin, Radcliffe saidon an episode of the Happy Sad Confused podcast in August 2021. Those were always the two characters that I was like, Theyre great.
Next, 41 Magical Harry Potter-Inspired Recipes That Will Instantly Transport You to Hogwarts
Will Jk Rowling Be In The Harrypotter Special On Hbo Max
One person who might not be hopping aboard the Hogwarts Express this time around? J.K. Rowling. The Harry Potter author, who has received backlash in recent years for comments many labeled as transphobic, was notably absent from the reunion announcement.
Rowling also didnt tweet about the reunion on the day it was announced, and the next day on her official Instagram, she shared a headline about the HBO Max special but didnt say that she would be a part of it.
Don’t Miss: Harry Potter’s First Broom
A Key Weapon Presented Itself
The Sword of Gryffindor had been an instrumental tool in destroying horcruxes throughout Harry Potter lore. Dumbledore used it to destroy the Gaunt family ring. Harry retrieved it from the frozen lake, after it presented itself to him, and Ron used it to destroy the locket that was causing his buddy so much mental anguish. Despite knowing its powers, Harry offered the sword to Griphook in exchange for him helping them get into Bellatrix Lestrange’s vault at Gringotts, and he made good on his end of the bargain.
Griphook returned to villainy soon after, though, and left Harry and his friends in a lurch, by abandoning them in the vault caverns with no promise to get them out. Hermione, always with a clever idea up her gown sleeve, led the trio to ride a dungeon-bound dragon out of the bank, with Griphook perishing in the fiery skirmish that ensued. The sword then disappeared from his grip, to present itself to a more worthy pair of hands.
Later on, when Hermione and Ron were back at Hogwarts trying to lure Nagini away from Voldemort, to destroy what was one of the final remaining horcruxes, the Sword presented itself to Neville Longbottom by way of the Sorting Hat, so he could slice the snake’s head off and give Voldemort one last crucial blow before he did his ultimate battle with Harry. Unlike other weapons of its ilk, the Sword knew no master, and simply chose whoever was worthiest at the time. And few were more worthy than Neville.