The Effects Of Polyjuice Potion Aren’t Consistent In The Films
When Ron and Harry use Polyjuice Potion to transform into Crabbe and Goyle in the second book, Harry’s thoughts read, “… Then he realized that his glasses were clouding his eyes because Goyle obviously didn’t need them he took them off and called, ‘Are you two okay?’ Goyle’s low rasp of a voice issued from his mouth.”
This clearly tells readers that under the effects of the potion you take on both the vision and voice of the person you’ve become. But this isn’t what we see play out in the films.
For one thing, in the second movie, Harry keeps his glasses on until Draco questions it, insinuating that he doesn’t get Goyle’s vision from drinking the potion. That also creates a discrepancy in “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1” when Hermione uses Polyjuice Potion to become Harry and remarks on how terrible his eyesight is.
Additionally, Ron and Harry maintain their own voices in the second movie, which is consistent with the characters who become Harry in the first “Deathly Hallows” film, but still inconsistent with the book’s description.
The inconsistencies continue when you take into account that when Barty Crouch Jr. uses Polyjuice Potion to impersonate Mad-Eye Moody in the fourth movie, his voice seemingly does transform.
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix
In the fifth book, Dumbledore is demoted from Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot, voted out of the Chairmanship of the International Confederation of Wizards, and is almost stripped of his Order of Merlin First Class due to his speeches regarding the return of Voldemort, although it is reported that he is unconcerned as long as he is not taken off the Chocolate Frog cards. Meanwhile, the Ministry of Magic does everything they can to discredit him and Harry mainly through the Daily Prophet. At the beginning of the book, Dumbledore enrages Fudge when he stops by at Harry’s hearing with a witness to ensure that he is not expelled. While Harry feels better when Dumbledore assists him, he becomes annoyed to the point of being angry that the headmaster refuses to speak to or even look at him.
Yes Dumbledore Did Ask Snape To Kill Him So Draco Wouldnt
Dumbledore did indeed ask Snape to kill him, so that Draco wouldnt either succeed and maim his own soul, or more likely fail and be killed by the Dark Lord for his almost inevitable failure.
All the same, try. I am concerned less for myself than for accidental victims of whatever schemes might occur to the boy. Ultimately, of course, there is only one thing to be done if we are to save him from Lord Voldemorts wrath.
Snape raised his eyebrows and his tone was sardonic as he asked, Are you intending to let him kill you?
Certainly not. You must kill me. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33
Dumbledore didnt want Draco to do it and harm his soul, but he also didnt want to die at the hands of someone who would prolong his death and make it more painful. He preferred that Snape kill him quickly, and since it was done as an act of mercy, Snapes soul would remain intact.
Its clear that Dumbledore did both ask and expect Snape to kill him, and this was always his plan.
After you have killed me, Severus
You refuse to tell me everything, yet you expect that small service of me! snarled Snape, and real anger flared in the thin face now. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 33
So yes, Dumbledore did indeed ask Snape to kill him to spare Draco the Dark Lords wrath or a maimed soul because of Dracos own attempts to kill Dumbledore.
Read Also: Order To Watch Harry Potter Movies
*** Thanksgiving Recipes ***
These roasted brussels sprouts get a fair amount of spice from the crushed red pepper flakes, which cuts
We love how the cinnamon-scented streusel topping lets the juicy berries peek through.
Poach quince in rosé with a dash of cocktail bitters and a few warm spices, then assemble into a tart
Alton Browns turkey brine recipe from Good Eats will give you a flavorful Thanksgiving turkey with juicy
Bone-in turkey breasts are easy to find, and as impressive as a whole bird when you roast them in butter
Leave the sausage, nuts, dried fruit behind in favor of this easy, vegetarian-friendly stuffing recipe
After trying every turkey-roasting method under the sun, Ive finally settled on this as absolutely the
Italian sausage and a heap of Parmesan cheese lend signature flair to the easy Thanksgiving dressing
Its all about the layers and ruffles in this dramatic seasonal pie.
This recipe was handed down by my great-grandmother. It is a family favorite that we make every Thanksgiving.
Cutting leeks into large pieces gives them a presence equal
This crunchy crumble is the perfect topping for an ice cream sundae, easy apple crumble, or our Build-Your-Own
I adapted this from a 50-year-old peach crisp recipe. Although it works well with peaches, it works even better with fresh, crisp cooking apples.
A simple dessert thats great served with ice cream.
It takes a little work, but it is worth it.
The Chapter That Made Us Fall In Love With Albus Dumbledore
Its important to note, first of all, that Albus Dumbledore was loved by us, and by you long before Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.
He was loved in Philosophers Stone, when he comforted Harry about the loss of his parents he was loved in Order of the Phoenix, where he faced off against Lord Voldemort he was loved in Half-Blood Prince, in which he sacrificed himself for the greater good. If anything, Albus Dumbledore is as much loved as Harry Potter himself maybe even more so.
And yet it wasnt until Deathly Hallows that we realised: did we ever really know Dumbledore? Or had we merely met him? Sure, we knew Dumbledore as well as Harry knew Dumbledore: as a kind, wise, lovely bearded headmaster as one of the wizarding worlds most famous figures as a wizard of incredible power and prestige. But know him?
To truly know someone, you have to go beyond the mystique of what they are, and find out who they were: the past that shaped them, the experiences and decisions that informed who they have become. And that is exactly what we got in Deathly Hallows… and especially the chapter Kings Cross.
Recommended Reading: Who Plays Voldemort In Deathly Hallows
Even If Dumbledore Would Be Able To Come Back He Wouldn’t This Is One Of The Primary Points Of The Books
Although I agree with the other answers that the questioner seems to have misunderstood the Hallows, I want to point out that even if Dumbledore would have been able to come back, he wouldn’t.
The primary theme of Harry Potter is about overcoming the fear of death:
Death is an extremely important theme throughout all seven books. I would say possibly the most important theme.
Voldemort’s main personality trait, and the one that defines him the most, is his fear of death.
Voldemort’s fear is death, ignominious death. I mean, he regards death itself as ignominious. He thinks that it’s a shameful human weakness, as you know. His worst fear is death, but how would a boggart show that? I’m not too sure. I did think about that because I knew you were going to ask me that.
There is nothing worse than death, Dumbledore! snarled Voldemort.
This is also his greatest weakness:
Your failure to understand that there are things much worse than death has always been your greatest weakness
In fact all the bad guys primary traits seem to be based on fear of death
Only innocent lives, Peter! You dont understand! whined Pettigrew. He would have killed me, Sirius!
However, the defining characteristic of the good guys is their willingness to embrace death. This is evident from the first book:
This is expressed in many other places in the books as well, but here’s one of my favorite quotes:
And Snape becomes good only when he seems to embrace death:
This Answer Is One Giant Spoiler And Most Spoilers Are There In The Open Sorry There’s No Way To Do It Without Them
Dumbledore’s Death was pre-arranged by Dumbledore and Snape back in The Half-Blood Prince :
Snape had to kill Dumbledore. Firstly, because it was an act of mercy for Dumbledore, as he was already dying, first from the curse he received when he put on the Gaunt ring, and second when he drank the potion from the cave with the locket horcrux. That’s what Dumbledore means when he says “Severus. Please.”.
Snape also had to kill Dumbledore to remain a trusted Death Eater, and Voldemort’s right hand. He needed to be a double agent in Voldemort’s ranks in order to be able to help Harry & Co on their quest, such as when he sent his doe Patronus to the lake where he hid the sword of Godric Gryffindor.
As to how Snape became a double agent – it was after Voldemort had become determined to kill Harry as an infant, thus endangering his mother, Lily, whom Snape love since they were children.
Snape begged Dumbledore to protect Lily however, Lily still died. Snape continued to serve Dumbledore as a double agent to honour her memory , which was living in her son
You May Like: What Is The Cure For Boils Harry Potter Hogwarts Mystery
Richard Harris Initially Didnt Want To Do The Harry Potter Films
Before agreeing to play the headmaster at Hogwarts, Harris admits that he was hesitant at first.
I was asked about the part of Dumbledore, and I wasnt going to do it for various reasons, Harris revealed. Then my granddaughter Ellie telephoned me and said, Papa, if you dont play Dumbledore, I will never speak to you again! So I didnt have much choice in it.
I would say that this is the most difficult part Ive ever played, he continued. Dumbledores presence is right through the books even though you dont see that much of him. Hes a very important figure in the stories, and I needed to find a rhythm and a meter in this beautifully written dialogue in order to be able to play the part.
According to Harry Potter: Page to Screen, Harris had a meaningful relationship with the young cast: particularly, with Rupert Grint.
Chris Columbus had asked me to come out to the studio to meet the young cast, and I came out to read with them, said Harris. When I finished the reading, the little boy playing Ron Weasley turned to me and said, Mr. Harris, that was quite a good reading. I think youll be quite good in this part! Its that kind of magic that is everywhere in this film.
Early Career At Hogwarts
- Dumbledore: I had proven, as a very young man, that power was my weakness and temptation. I was safer at Hogwarts. I think I was a good teacher.
- Harry Potter: You were the best.
- A discussion in limbo regarding power and leadership
Shortly thereafter, Albus, who had been exchanging owls with the famous researcher as far back when he had been a student at Hogwarts, travelled to France and spent some time in Paris studying the ancient art and science of alchemy under the tutelage of Nicholas Flamel. He presumably did so in order to both give his brother some space, as well as to get away for a bit and spend his time grieving more productively than he otherwise would have done simply wallowing in his own misery. It is unknown when exactly he returned to Britain, but around the time he did, Albus had become intrigued with the study of dragons blood, and was ultimately credited with the discovery of no less than twelve new uses for it ) an accomplishment that earned him widespread recognition and ultimately played no small role in the subsequent offer he received of a teaching position at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Having always had a deep fondness for the old school and felt drawn towards teaching even as a student, Albus was happy to accept.
Don’t Miss: What Would I Be In Harry Potter
Harry Potter Theory: What Was Dumbledores Actual Plan
The Harry Potter series is one of the most beloved stories of this generation, but its not without its flaws. J. K. Rowling is a very good storyteller, but not a very good world-builder, and the closer you look at her stories, the more plot holes you see. The end of Deathly Hallows has always been especially difficult for me to understand. For one, its not entirely clear what actually happenedwhy, exactly, Harry survived and how he later wonbut theres a deeper problem. I have a hard time understanding what Albus Dumbledore was thinking, because Harrys victory, which Dumbledore ostensibly prepared him for, seemed to leave far, far too much to chance to ever work.
Albus Dumbledore gets a lot of criticism for his actions over the course of the Harry Potter series. Many fans even go so far as to suggest that he was acting maliciously, or at least callously and indifferently in his treatment of Harry. ou have been raising him like a pig for slaughter, Snape says , but on that, I disagree. I think its clear that Dumbledore didnt know a lot of important things until late in the game. Voldemort had him on the back foot, and he was searching for answers that might not exist.
This essay is my analysis of what that original plan was and where Dumbledores true mistakes were.
All Hallows Eve, 1981
And then, the unthinkable happens: he is fatally cursed by the horcrux.
The Half-Blood Prince
The Will of Albus Dumbledore
The Deathly Hallows
Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire
In the fourth novel, Dumbledore introduces the Triwizard Tournament. He also serves as a judge during the entire event. When Harry’s name comes out of the Goblet of Fire, Dumbledore is not enraged, but remains calm simply asking Harry whether he had himself, or had asked an older student to submit his name ” rel=”nofollow”> film version he does get angry to the point of manhandling Harry). When Harry answers no, he believes him. By the end of the book, Dumbledore’s fears are realized when Harry returns from his encounter with Voldemort clutching the dead body of Cedric Diggory and when Mad-Eye Moody takes Harry away from Dumbledore and to his office inside the castle. Dumbledore immediately becomes suspicious and heads straight towards Moody’s office with Minerva McGonagall and Severus Snape to save Harry and to interrogate Crouch. Afterwards, Dumbledore listens to Harry’s eyewitness account about Voldemort’s return. Harry though, only wakes up later to find Minister for Magic Cornelius Fudge in the hospital wing arguing with McGonagall and Dumbledore about the situation of Voldemort’s return and the consequences that would follow should Fudge remain in denial of this fact.
Read Also: Voldemort Harry Potter Actor
Hermione Never Fixed Harry’s Glasses In The Sorcerer’s Stone Book
In “Sorcerer’s Stone” Hermione uses the “Oculus Reparo” spell to fix Harry’s glasses on the Hogwarts Express. But this goes against the rule prohibiting underage magic outside of school, which Hermione would absolutely know about from studying “Hogwarts: A History.”
The books don’t include this contradiction because Hermione doesn’t use the spell.
Harry’s glasses only need mending once, in “Chamber of Secrets,” and it’s Mr. Weasley who performs the fixing spell.
Albus Dumbledore’s Mother Kendra Died While Caring For Ariana
With Percival in Azkaban, the responsibility to raise the Dumbledore children fell on his half-Muggle wife Kendra. Albus and Aberforth were well enough on their own after time, but Ariana required constant surveillance due to her fragile condition. Kendra passed away following an event that was believed to involve an outburst by Ariana, although the full details of what happened are unclear.
That blank spot in the Dumbledore family timeline could hold the key to how Credence came into the picture. For example, the outburst could’ve been Ariana in the process of childbirth, the result of which ended up killing Kendra. Again though, for Credence to be Albus’ brother, it’d have to be Kendra who gave birth. Percival was in Azkaban for a long time, so perhaps his mother took another secret lover when Albus was away? It feels unlikely, but possible.
Read Also: What Harry Potter House Are You Pottermore
Camelot A Man Called Horse
Harris next performed the role of King Arthur in the film adaptation of the musical play Camelot . Critic Roger Ebert described the casting of Harris and Vanessa Redgrave as “about the best King Arthur and Queen Guenevere I can imagine”. Harris revived the role in a Broadway revival at the Winter Garden Theatre from 15 November 1981, to 2 January 1982, and broadcast on HBO a year later. Starring Meg Bussert as Guenevere, Richard Muenz as Lancelot and Thor Fields as Tom of Warwick. Harris, who had starred in the film, and Muenz also took the show on tour nationwide.
In The Molly Maguires , he played James McParland, the detective who infiltrates the title organisation, headed by Sean Connery. It was a box office flop. However A Man Called Horse , with Harris in the title role, an 1825 English aristocrat who is captured by Native Americans, was a major success.