Friday, May 17, 2024

Why Was Hermione Not In Ravenclaw

Don't Miss

She Is Full Of Wisdom

Why Hermione Wasn’t in RAVENCLAW – Harry Potter Theory

Luna might be wacky remember those radish earrings? but that doesnt mean shes short of wisdom, quite the opposite. Were thinking in particular about that moment she talked to Harry about grief and loss, after Sirius was killed at the Ministry of Magic. She shared the personal story of her mums death at a time Harry really needed to hear it, and reminded him that the ones we love never truly leave us:

Yes, it was rather horrible, said Luna conversationally. I still feel very sad about it sometimes. But Ive still got Dad. And anyway, its not as though Ill never see Mum again, is it?Er isnt it? said Harry uncertainly.She shook her head in disbelief.Oh, come on. You heard them, just behind the veil, didnt you?You mean …In that room with the archway. They were just lurking out of sight, thats all. You heard them.

But its not just emotions she has words of wisdom about, she was always prepared when it came to her habit of sleep walking:

Ive never been to this part of the castle. At least not while awake. I sleep walk, you see. Thats why I wear shoes to bed.

What House Was Hermione Supposed To Be In

Usually, students get sorted to their respective Houses relatively fast.

We saw that with Ron Weasley and Draco Malfoy during the first book. However, a hat stall refers to the rare situation where the Sorting Hat takes five minutes or longer to decide in what house the person should belong.

When Harry started his journey in Hogwarts, only two people in his generation were close to this scenario. Neville Longbottom between Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, and Hermione Granger between Gryffindor and Ravenclaw.

Terry Boot: How come youre not in Ravenclaw? With brains like yours?

Hermione: Well, the Sorting Hat did seriously consider putting me in Ravenclaw during my Sorting, but it decided on Gryffindor in the end.

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix

What Makes A Hufflepuff

Hufflepuff is one of the four Houses of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Its founder was the medieval witch Helga Hufflepuff. Hufflepuff is the most inclusive among the four houses valuing hard work, dedication, patience, loyalty, and fair play rather than a particular aptitude in its members.

Read Also: Is Harry Potter Disney

Who Is Stronger Harry Or Hermione

Hermione excels at school more than Harry in all subjects except for one. In the books, Harrys O.W.L. results for DADA are higher than Hermiones, the only exam in which he outperformed her. His defensive abilities are an asset for the young wizard that gives him an edge over his best friend in combat.

Did Hermione Kiss Draco

Why is Hermione Granger in Gryffindor not in Ravenclaw ...

One day, Draco decides to erase Hermiones memories. During the Battle of Hogwarts, Hermione and Draco reunite on the room of requirement. Thats a symbolic place for them cause thats where they exchanged their first kiss, thats why Hermione recovers her memories but its too late since shes already with Ron.

Recommended Reading: Harry Potter Online Test

Did Anyone Choose To Be Sorted Into Hufflepuff

Harry, Ron and Hermione all could have ended in other houses, namely Slytherin, Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw. Yet they ended up in Gryffindor due to their innate, though at that time undiscovered, courage.

As Dumbledore states, “I think maybe we sort too soon”, which implies that the Hat does not choose based on potential, but rather on current student persona, and we know that the Hat takes user preference into account. It stands to reason that people might want to be in Ravenclaw, for the extreme potential for knowledge acquisition. Being in Gryffindor, the House of Heroes, or in Slytherin, the House for people who want to gain personal power, are also logical choices for most people.

Is there a known case of someone choosing to be in Hufflepuff, or do you get there if you’re too dumb to be in Ravenclaw, too weak to be a Gryffindor and not ambitious enough to be a Slytherin?

  • 6Based on your “criteria”, Hermione is too dumb to be in Ravenclaw, not hardworking enough to be in Hufflepuff, and not cunning enough to be in Slytherin. Does that sound right?Dec 17 ’17 at 15:30
  • 1

Which Hogwarts House Is The Most Dangerous


Speaking of stereotypes, Slytherin is undoubtedly the house that gets the most negative rep and is often called an evil house, or at least a bad house that only produces dark wizards with little to none redeeming attributes. This is not true, however, as Slytherins have a lot of great traits.

You May Like: Wizard Robe Sewing Pattern

Dumbledore Is Willing To Sacrifice Himself For Other People

Dumbledore is one of the most selfless people in the wizarding world, the staple of a true Gryffindor. Even in his death, he was self-sacrificial and knew that he needed to create a plan for Severus Snape to kill him for the greater good.

He also frequently takes the blame for others. For example, when Dolores Umbridge finds out about Dumbledores Army.

This act saves Harry, Ron, Hermione, and all the other members of Dumbledores Army from being expelled .

In their own unique ways, Slytherins and Ravenclaws are loyal to their own. However, Ravenclaws would use their intellect, and Slytherins would use their cleverness to find creative ways out of situations.

Their first instinct is not to sacrifice themselves for someone they barely know.

Hermione Was The Slytherin We Needed

reasons why harry potter is not in ravenclaw

Hermione was written as a Slytherin. She has the mind, heart, and moral compass of one, even if her blood status doesnt comply with Salazar Slytherins ideals.

Reading the Harry Potter series entirely from Harrys perspective, were subjected to his biased view of the world. Harry thought Slytherins to be evil so thats what we saw.

A great opportunity was missed in the series to show a Slytherin student in a positive light. Had Hermione, one of the lead characters and best friend to the Chosen One, been a Slytherin, there would have been yet another great lesson in the series, that of breaking prejudice.

A muggle-born in Slytherin would have shattered the notion that blood purity matters in magical ability. Not to mention, having Hermione specifically in Slytherin would have demonstrated a cross-house friendship that was much needed in the series.

Of course, 19 years later we got some house diversity in the form of a Potter in Slytherin, and a Slytherin Malfoy that wasnt a prat. But Cursed Child canon isnt quite the same as Harry Potter canon.

You May Like: Would Draco Malfoy Date You Quiz

What Is Your Patronus

Harry Potter Patronus List. The spell is cast when a person says, “Expecto Patronum,” and for the witches and wizards who can cast it, a silvery-white guardian spews out of the wand taking the form of an animal. A Patronus Charm is adefensive spell used to protect a witch or wizard against Dementors.

Why Is Gilderoy Lockhart Ravenclaw

Gilderoy LockhartRavenclaw

. Just so, why it’s great to be a Ravenclaw?

Ravenclaw is the house for ‘those of wit and learning’, which can lead to deep intuition in a friendship as well as, say, achieving ‘Oustanding’ in all N.E.W.T.s. Ravenclaws pay attention to the world around them and that also means paying attention to their friends.

Also Know, why is Hermione Granger not in Ravenclaw? And this is why Hermione does not fit into Ravenclaw, since she lacks their creativity of thought. When you also add in her fearlessness and her strong convictions about right and wrong, which are inherently Gryffindor traits, then there was even less of a chance she’d end up wearing blue and bronze.

Subsequently, question is, was Gilderoy Lockhart evil?

Lockhart before unsuccessfully attempting to erase Harry and Ron’s memories. Gilderoy Lockhart is a prominent villain in J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, and its 2002 film adaptation of the same name. He is a famous author and temporary Defense Against the Dark Arts professor at Hogwarts.

What house was Gilderoy Lockhart?

Ravenclaw house

You May Like: Scotland Harry Potter Castle

Why Want Hermione A Ravenclaw

Rowena Ravenclaw, the founder of the house, favors education and intelligence above all else, and Hermione has been considered to be « the brightest witch of her age ». It seems only fitting that she would be placed in the house of Ravenclaw instead of Gryffindor because she is just so brilliant and all-knowing.

Creation For Books And Films

Harry Potter: 5 Reasons Hermione Should Have Been In ...

Rowling has suggested that she may have inadvertently taken the name from the hogwort plant , which she had seen at Kew Gardens some time before writing the series, although the names “The Hogwarts” and “Hoggwart” appear in the 1954 Nigel Molesworth book How to Be Topp by Geoffrey Willans.

Most exterior scenes were shot on location at Alnwick Castle, but views of the exterior of the entire school were created from shots of Durham Cathedral with a digital spire added to the towers. Durham Cathedral also served as a set for Hogwarts interiors.

A scale model was created for exterior shots of the entire school. Models of Alnwick Castle and Durham Cathedral were also built to create more integration between the model and on location shots. It took a team of 86 artists and crew members 74 years worth of man hours to complete the model.

Read Also: Syfy Harry Potter Weekend

Could Albus Dumbledore Have Passed As A Slytherin

Its no secret that Dumbledore could sometimes be cunning, ambitious, and even manipulative. Perhaps the most calculated thing he did was keep it to himself that Harry would eventually have to die to defeat Voldemort.

We understand that it couldve been disastrous and created more problems if he had told Harry. Regardless, Dumbledore still chose to be secretive about it.

However, does this mean he belonged in Slytherin House instead? Not necessarily. The Sorting Hat placed Dumbledore in Gryffindor for a reason.

The Hat mustve known that he would live up to the Gryffindor legacy of being brave, daring, and courageous.

Why Is Hermione Not A Ravenclaw

And this is why Hermione does not fit into Ravenclaw, since she lacks their creativity of thought. When you also add in her fearlessness and her strong convictions about right and wrong, which are inherently Gryffindor traits, then there was even less of a chance she’d end up wearing blue and bronze.

Don’t Miss: Which One Of The Weasley Twins Died

Harry Potter: Why Hermione Isn’t In Ravenclaw

Part of what makes the Harry Potter franchise so endearing through the years is its talent to take the most obvious and subvert it, but reasonably than make these subversion massive, they are nearly at all times incredibly subtle. Some nice examples come with why Voldemort used to be never the owner of the Elder Wand. However, because of these slight adjustments that help the story, additionally they carry many questions. One instance of this comprises the lingering query of why Hermione Granger used to be by no means a Ravenclaw.

Each house in Harry Potter has its personal traits which are discovered in all of its scholars. For instance, Gryffindor is understood for its bravery, while Hufflepuff is known for its loyalty. That being said, Ravenclaws are extra bookish and intellectual, however as an alternative of leaning on e-book smarts, they take their herbal interest and push the boundaries of what is normal. A perfect instance of this in action is with characters like Luna Lovegood. Although very smart, she’s known for appearing in opposition to the grain along with her personal style and standout personality.

RELATED: Harry Potter: The Wizarding Worlds Worst Sport Could Make A Great Movie


Hermione Is Extremely Wise

Why Hermione Granger should’ve been in Ravenclaw

It’s one thing to get an A+ score on a charms test, and it’s another thing to be filled with endless wisdom. Sometimes wisdom is more powerful than intelligence, as is evident with Albus Dumbledore. Luckily for Hermione, she seems to be just as wise as she is brilliant. This is especially evident in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone when she says to Harry: “Me, books and cleverness- There are far more important things like friendship and bravery.” This is a quote that proves this girl is wise beyond her years. 10 points to Gryffindor!

Also Check: Harry Potter Sorcerer’s Stone Word Count

How Can You Tell A Ravenclaw

11 Signs Youre A Ravenclaw, Which You Were Obviously Smart Enough To Know Already

  • Youre A Nerd About *Something*
  • Youre « The Creative One » Of Your Friends.
  • Youre Also « The Smart One »
  • Youre Witty AF.
  • Youre Only Reading This List Because You Ran Out Of Books.
  • Youre Hyper Competetive.
  • You Love Fellow Weirdos.
  • What Are The 4 House Colors In Harry Potter

    Green. One of the colours of Slytherin house, green is associated with Dark magic, jealousy and Harry Potter’s eyes. Like Gryffindor’s colours, the green and silver of Slytherin are connected to the element they most closely represent, water. In wider folklore, green has long had a supernatural connection.

    Recommended Reading: Harry Potter Marathon Today

    Could Albus Dumbledore Have Passed As A Ravenclaw

    Albus Dumbledore was brilliant and frequently used his intellect and quick wit to creatively get out of challenging situations.

    It also takes a wise and well-educated witch or wizard to be Headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. However, as you will see in this article, these were not his only traits.

    All of these traits collectively seem like he may have been a good Ravenclaw. Although technically, it wasnt even his intellect that people most respected him for, it was his bravery and a strong sense of doing the right thing.

    He wouldnt have done well as a studious, strict Ravenclaw.

    Why Is Hermione Not In Ravenclaw

    Newt and Hermione: Why Two of the Smartest Characters Are ...

    hey its amberthefish here and i wanted to put this question here because im sure a lot of people wonder about it. i have a few reasons:

    firstly, remember that intelligence isnt the only quality of being a Ravenclaw. There is also wit, creativity, and uniqueness. although Hermione is smart, she lacks creativity. she is only book smart, which can be useful but doesnt require wit.

    for example, in book 1, when they are entangled in devils snare, some might think Hermione is witty and quick on her feet. in truth, she acted more like a gryffindor by staying calm and being brave. she remembers that rhyme from her herbology book, which i admit is clever, but a real Ravenclaw would probably think up a new solution.

    of course, everyone has traits from each house so the sorting hat has to decide which ones stand out most. perhaps the same thing happened to Hermione as it did to Harry when he was being sorted, except with Ravenclaw instead of Slytherin. who knows?

    lastly, to prove that Hermione definitely isnt a Ravenclaw, in book 7 when Luna takes Harry to the Ravenclaw common room and she has to answer the question: What came first, the phoenix or the flame? . Luna gives a very creative and witty answer: a circle has no beginning. Hermione would have probably spent ages trying to figure out a logical answer to the question, when any witty answer would have probably been accepted.


    Don’t Miss: Harry Potter Cast Dumbledore Actor

    Does That Mean Jk Rowling Was Also Wrong Yes Yes It Does

    Its rare that the Sorting Hat ever gets a sorting wrong , but when it comes to Hermione Granger, the hat definitely made a mistake.

    It isnt that Hermione shouldnt be in Gryffindor, or shouldnt be in Ravenclaw , its that Slytherin is the best fit for her. The only reason Hermione wasnt put in Slytherin is because shes muggleborn. Way to perpetuate Slytherins elitist mentality, Sorting Hat

    A singular trait isnt enough to place you in a house, no matter how dominant it is. Hermione is intelligent, but that doesnt automatically mean shes a Ravenclaw. Hermione is brave, but that doesnt automatically mean shes a Gryffindor. Ambition, resourcefulness, cunning, cleverness, and fraternalism are all traits Hermione Granger possesses. They are also all traits of a Slytherin.

    Hermione Is The Brightest Witch Of Her Age

    So this one is pretty obvious, but it’s definitely significant as to why Hermione would be excellent in the house of Ravenclaw. Rowena Ravenclaw, the founder of the house, favors education and intelligence above all else, and Hermione has been considered to be “the brightest witch of her age”. It seems only fitting that she would be placed in the house of Ravenclaw instead of Gryffindor because she is just so brilliant and all-knowing.

    You May Like: Diy Harry Potter Robes

    Why Would Hermione Not Fit In Ravenclaw

    Its an endless debate whether Hermione should have gone to Ravenclaw instead. After all, Hermione is the greatest witch of her generation, has always poured a lot of passion and effort into her studies and her knowledge seems to know almost no boundaries.

    However, we have four clear arguments that prove that her place was always in Gryffindor.

    Before continuing, we all know that the Sorting Hat decides the students fate at Hogwarts. During their first year, the Sorting Hats song describes both houses as it follows:

    You might belong inGryffindor,

    Where dwell the brave at heart,

    Their daring, nerve, and chivalry

    Set Gryffindors apart

    Or yet in wise oldRavenclaw,

    if youve a ready mind,

    Where those of wit and learning,

    Will always find their kind

    Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone, Chapter 7

    With that out of the way, lets continue:

    Why Is Hermione Not In Slytherin

    Why Harry Potter isnt in Ravenclaw (Not Mine)

    The only reason Hermione wasnt put in Slytherin is because shes muggleborn. . Hermione is brave, but that doesnt automatically mean shes a Gryffindor. Ambition, resourcefulness, cunning, cleverness, and fraternalism are all traits Hermione Granger possesses. They are also all traits of a Slytherin.

    Read Also: Who Gives Harry The Nimbus 2000

    More articles

    Popular Articles