Thursday, May 16, 2024

What Is Better Harry Potter Or Lord Of The Rings

Don't Miss

Voldemort Is No Balrog

Lord of the Rings vs. Harry Potter | Rotten Tomatoes

One of the most well-known lines in literature/movies is “You shall not pass!” from;Lord of the Rings. Then there’s the huge resemblance between;Gandalf and Dumbledore.

Despite the fact that the characters were played by two different actors, they look so similar that people who don’t know would easily assume they’re the same person. So it makes sense that Dumbledore could “accidentally” say a Gandalf line because they look so similar, even though they are not played by the same actor. They also have the same role in the movie: play the wise wizard who seems to be the father figure and mentor of the coming of age person. JK Rowling had to have come under the spotlight for how similar these two characters seemed.

This is as much of a classic Lord of the Rings/Harry Potter;meme as you could possibly get.

Dont The Great Tales Never End

The Lord of the Rings consists of six distinct books, despite being published in only three volumes.

Book One concerns the four hobbits journey to Rivendell and spends a good deal of that time just developing the main characters.

After the Council of Elrond at the start of Book Two, the story begins to move more quickly, with the Fellowship beginning their journey to Mordor.

Book Two ends when the members of the Fellowship go their separate ways at Amon Hen.; The third, fourth, and fifth books detail the War of the Ring and the quest of Frodo and Sam, with Book Six following the hobbits in the years after the Rings destruction.

Is The Book Better Than The Movie

Its an age-old debate, which is better, the book or the movie? We analyzed over 1,100 books and compared them to their movie adaptations to see which fans prefer.

From Harry Potter to The Lord of The Rings to James Bond, we took a deep dive in an attempt to solve the book vs. movie debate.

Once youve finished comparing, be sure to check out some of the top streaming services to see where you can catch up on these great films.

Recommended Reading: What Did Dumbledore See In The Mirror

Why I Like Harry Potter Better Than Lord Of The Rings

I’m not arguing that “Harry Potter” is actually — in some objective sense — better than “Lord of the Rings.” I get that “Lord of the Rings” is probably Great Art, and I’m not sure that “Harry Potter” is.

What I’m saying is that I enjoy “Harry Potter” immeasurably more than “Lord of the Rings.” With “Harry Potter,” I eagerly look forward to each new installment in the series. I re-read the books frequently and with pleasure; I have an extensive memory of the story, and can discuss its finer points at length; and I have an elaborate and probably unhealthy fantasy life centering around the Potterverse.

“Lord of the Rings,” on the other hand, I slogged through twenty years ago out of a sense of duty. I found it tedious and unengaging, and skimmed through long sections of it; I’ve never had the slightest desire to re-read it even once; I have only the vaguest memory of the general outline of the plot ; and I couldn’t tell you the names of more than four or five characters — and that only because those names get tossed around so much in conversation. “Lord of the Rings” is like Wagner or Bob Dylan to me — I recognize and acknowledge its greatness, without actually liking or enjoying it.

And I think this is a defensible position.

So I’m going to defend it.

Here’s what I think “Harry Potter” has that “Lord of the Rings” doesn’t.

But here’s the thing about female characters in “Harry Potter”:

It has some.

More than a couple, even.

Grab That Book And Start Reading

Harry Potter VS Lord of the Rings (Which do you like more ...

Sorry movie-goers, when it comes down to an analysis, the majority of books score higher than their film adaptations. It appears readers win this argument over film buffs.

Then again, who says you can only enjoy your entertainment a single way? Work your way through a series of novels, then hit up Netflix to watch the latest adaptation.

If you find that your movie-watching experience isnt streaming so smoothly, you may also want to check out the best internet providers for a more reliable connection.

Don’t Miss: Who Reads The Harry Potter Audio Books

Welcome To Rharrypotter The Place Where Fans From Around The World Can Meet And Discuss Everything In The Harry Potter Universe

Why lord of the rings is better than harry potter. The LOTR is HANDS DOWN better than Harry Potter. A protagonist defined by his burden a secretive but overwhelmingly evil villain and the face-off that happens directly or indirectly between these two opposing forces. The LOTR movies are actually quite boring sometimes whereas Harry Potter is always interesting and awesome.

Lord of the Rings is better than Harry Potter. Indeed Tolkien even went so far as to create not just one but several new languages entirely of his own making including Elvish Dwarvish Entish and Black Speech. Franchises as diverse as X-Men to.

One hears far more about Harry Potter than Lord of the Rings. Ugh I hate the movies compared to the books. Part 1 of 6 The Hobbit.

On the other hand I think I have better jokes Both Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings have reignited an eras love for fantasy almost single-handedly. Harry Potter is better than Lord of the Rings Due to the fact that Harry Potter is loved by so many I feel that it is better than Lord of the Rings. Which is better Harry Potter or The Lord Of Rings.

Why this it much better is because we are understanding what is happening everywhere that is where the protagonists are at the current moment. Tarek Pinnock 13 said. There is so much emotion in them that you could cry laugh and throw your book at the wall all at the same time.

LOTR Characters Sorted Into Hogwarts Houses.

Movies Movies Best Funny Pictures Indiana Jones

Harry Potter And The Lord Of The Rings

Article ID: DH263 | By: Mark Ryan and Carole Hausmann Ryan

This article first appeared in the News Watch department of the Christian Research Journal, volume 24, number 4 . For further information or to subscribe to the Christian Research Journal go to:

The blockbuster films about Middle Earth and Harry Potter have given Christians two opportunities to respond to magical fantasy on the big screen. The first installment of The Lord of the Rings trilogy and of the Harry Potter series were released during the past winter movie season. Christians apparently find it easier to accept the magic and wizardry of J. R. R. Tolkiens Gandalf than J. K. Rowlings Harry.

As news correspondents for the Journal and Christian parents, we saw both Harry Potter and the Sorcerers Stone and multiple Oscar-winning The Fellowship of the Ring and interviewed other Christian parents about their views regarding these two movies. We loved both movies. We highly recommend both to most people, but not everyone. The Lord of the Rings is a story of a monumental struggle between good and evil, full of war and suffering and death. It is not for small children nor faint-hearted adults. It is also not for people who do not like fantasy even superb fantasy. As one of our friends commented, The Lord of the Rings has a dark shadow of foreboding over it: Tolkiens dark lord casts his long shadow over the whole tale, and the movie conveys this foreboding heartbreakingly, breathtakingly well.

Read Also: Were Dumbledore And Grindelwald Lovers

Another Gandalf V Dumbledore

In this meme, were back to the conversation about Gandalf vs. Dumbledore. There are plenty of these memes to go around. This one compares specific things that Gandalf and Dumbledore do, to determine who rocks the hardest. First, Gandalf wears a large wizarding hat, and Dumbledore wears a little smaller beanie.;Who do you think is better dressed?

Do you prefer a staff or a wand? A flashlight or the ability to turn off candles? Meddling middle-earth hobbits or meddling children to do your work?

According to this meme, it doesnt matter in the end, because Gandalf took care of his beard better. Let it be known for all future long-bearded wizards: beard-keeping is important in your life! It can make or break your career!

These type of memes are the best, theyre the epitome of not taking anything too seriously.

Lord Of The Rings Book Trilogy

Harry Potter VS Lord of the Rings: Which Magic Is More Powerful?

The Lord of the Rings is an epic high fantasy trilogy of novels by the English author and scholar J. R. R. Tolkien. Set in Middle-earth, the world at some distant time in the past, the story began as a sequel to Tolkiens 1937 childrens book The Hobbit, but eventually developed into a much larger work.

It is one of the best-selling books ever written, with over 200 million copies sold, and the total revenue from the books earnings is estimated to be around $2.5 billion.

Recommended Reading: What Is Hermione’s Favorite Color

The Scouring Of The Shire

After Sam shows Gollum mercy, leading to the Ring falling into the Cracks of Doom, Frodo and Sam await their deaths as the mountain of fire explodes.; Gandalf saves them, however, and they wake up in Ithilien.; Aragorn is crowned king of Gondor, and everything seems well.; But when the four hobbits return to the Shire, they find it conquered by the last remnants of Sarumans army.

The hobbits of the Shire fight a bloody battle only for Saruman to be killed on the doorstep of Bag End.; Only by Sams box of elven soil is the Shire healed somewhat.

Sam later marries Rose Cotton, and they eventually have a daughter named Elanor.; Frodo, bearing wounds that will never fully heal, leaves Middle-earth with the elves, leaving Sam to return to his family.; The book ends as Samwise arrives home:

He drew a deep breath.; Well, Im back, he said.

The Return of the King

Which Is Better The Book Or The Movie

The TL;DR is that the book is almost always better than the movie.

In our review of over 1,100 books, we found that the book was rated higher than the movie 89% percent of the timethats 9 out of 10 book-to-movie adaptations!

Readers also came out in higher numbers to rate their favorite books. Most written works had over 265k ratings, while most movies had only 109k ratings.

Curious what books made it to the silver screen more than others? James Bond is the clear winner in this department, having 15 more movies than the next runner-up, Harry Potter.

Don’t Miss: When Was The First Harry Potter Book Made

How Can You Argue This Look At The Numbers

Harry Potter books have sold over 500 mil copies where as Lord of the rings books have sold 150 mil. Yes there are more potter books, But they also came out four decades later and they still have already sold more copies per book. You can argue which you like more, But the best book series is by far Harry Potter, Since the point of a book series is to entertain the most amount of people. I love both and depending on my mood love one more then the other. I would argue LOTR is a more impressive story in its creativity but the best book series of all time is HP.

  • Submit
  • Lord Of The Ring Vs Harry Potter Memes That Prove The Rivalry Is Real

    Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets vs The Lord of the ...

    The Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter are the two ultimate fantasy book and movie series. But fans can never agree which one is the best.

    When you think of reading phenomena, most likely;Harry Potter and;Lord of the Rings come to mind as two of the biggest series in the recent literature. However, it wasn’t until the books came to movies that the rivalry between the two worlds, or fandoms, really began. When the characters from the two series came alive, the similarities and the differences came together to start a fun rivalry between the;two classic fantasy series.

    Parts of;Lord of the Rings can be found in other text, just like;Harry Potter probably has parts that are reminiscent of Lord of the Rings. Also, when the characters came to the big screen, there were obvious similarities. The mentor of both books were wizards with;long white beards. The actors;who played the protagonists even looked similar!

    Most of all, when two;fantasy;movie series come out in relatively short time to one another, they’re going to be compared. Especially when the movies overlap;in release. There’s going to be people who prefer one to another and people who like both but still can’t help but prefer one. And that’s where the memes come in!

    Here are;15 Lord Of The Rings Vs Harry Potter Memes.

    You May Like: Is Harry Potter Magical Realism

    Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire

    The Goblet Of Fire;sees Harry in his fourth year of Hogwarts as he is forced into competing in the dangerous Tri-Wizard tournament all the while Lord Voldemort finds his way back to physical form, and power.

    The movie earned its 7.7/10 from 509,173 reviews. The movie gained acclaim for its maturing characters and coinciding maturing craftsmanship, with its special effects and solid ensemble performances earning it well-deserved love.

    Frodo Baggins Vs Harry Potter

    Both stories feature a young male protagonist who sacrifices himself for the sake of others, generally as in both LOTR and Potter the whole world. Frodo Baggins and Harry Potter are two of the most famous fantasy heroes. Readers and movie-goers have cheered for them, but which hero is truly the most fascinating?

    Read Also: How Old Was Emma Watson In Harry Potter 2

    The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King

    Return Of The King;is the unbelievable conclusion to the trilogy and sees Frodo and Sam reach Mordor to destroy the one ring, all the while Aragorn leads the forces of good against the evil of Sauron’s army at Minas Tirith.

    The trilogy’s final entry earned an incredible 8.9/10 on IMDb with 1,555,111 reviews. The movie swept at the Oscars with 11 Academy Awards including Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Adapted Screenplay among a load of others and is widely regarded as one of the best final chapters to one of the finest cinematic trilogies of all time.

    Harry Potter And The Sorcerer’s Stone

    HARRY POTTER vs LORD OF THE RINGS – Fight for the glory

    The kickoff of the entire;Harry Potter;universe comes in;The Sorcerer’s Stone;which follows Harry in his first year of Hogwarts as he makes close friends, bitter rivals, and encounters his arch-enemy, doing all this while navigating school and magical life.

    From 593,624 reviews, the film gained a 7.9/10. Heralded for its book-to-screen adaptation while being a jam-packed, exciting introduction to the magical world of Potter,;Sorcerer’s Stone;may be a bit on the childish side but is an immensely fun adventure.

    Don’t Miss: Will There Be Another Harry Potter Movie

    The Sword Of Gryffindor

    A thousand-year-old l sword owned by the famed wizard Godric Gryffindor, one of the four founders of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft. It was made from pure silver by goblins, the magical worlds most skilled metalworkers, and is therefore enchanted.

    Much like a wand, the sword of Gryffindor appears to be almost sentient, responding to appeals for help by Gryffindors chosen successors.

    Since it is made from Goblins silver it never requires cleaning. Due to Harry Potter killing Salazar Slytherins Basilisk with it, the sword is imbued with Basilisk venom and can destroy Horcruxes an object in which a;dark wizard or witch has hidden a fragment of his or her;soul in order to become;immortal.

    The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring

    The Fellowship Of The Ring;is the beginning of the epic trilogy and follows the future of civilization fall onto the finger of Frodo, as he comes in possession of the one ring which must be destroyed at Mount Doom, an almighty task which sets him and our heroes off on a turbulent journey.

    The film earned its amazing 8.8/10 from big 1,566,942 reviews. The movie became a phenomenon for its excellent ensemble cast, its stunning effects, and just for overall being a perfect visualization of Tolkien’s legendary novel.

    Don’t Miss: Who Gives Harry Potter The Nimbus 2000

    Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows: Part 1

    The kickoff of the;Harry Potter;finale,;Deathly Hallows: Part 1;sees our trio of heroes on the run from;Voldemort and Death Eaters who have taken over the entire magical world, all while they search for Horcruxes to defeat the Dark Lord.

    From 444,117 reviews,;Deathly Hallows: Part 1;earned 7.7/10. Critics and fans alike pointed to the visual stunningness of the movie as well as its emotional touch as reasons to love it, but a common criticism is the fact it at all times feels like a build-up to the next movie, rather than its own.

    And The Award Goes To

    Response to the "Harry Potter vs Lord of the rings" post ...

    Sometimes, when bragging rights are due, they have to be recognized. Above all, the biggest thing that could possibly happen to a movie is to be;win an Academy Award. In the franchise, Harry Potter was nominated three times but never went on to win any of its nominations.

    However, Lord of the Rings was nominated 31 times and won 17 of those nominations. Out of both franchises, Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit, no;film did better than The Return of the King, which won every Academy Award it was nominated for, including Best Picture. Its been hard since to find a movie in the fantasy category that has done as well as Lord of the Rings.

    Sometimes, you have to give where the bragging rights are due. Nominations are good, but 17 wins are well, hard to beat!

    Also Check: How Many Characters In Harry Potter

    More articles

    Popular Articles