What Are The Consequences Of Time Travel In Harry Potter
Thanks to the keen wit and rule following of Hermione Granger, and with some help from Harry Potter of course, Buckbeak and Sirius Black are allowed to escape into the night. With their freedom won, and their lives spared, Sirius can now go into hiding, hoping that his name will be cleared and that things will die down enough for Harry to be able to come live with him. However, dark times wait ahead, as the course of events in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban werent changed so much as to alter historys flow too heavily.
Peter Pettigrew still escapes from captivity, and Professor Remus Lupin resigns after its revealed to the world at large that he is, in fact, a werewolf. So the world of Harry Potter keeps turning in the same orbit that we would have expected, by and large. But when it comes to Buckbeak and Sirius, those changes are definitely large enough to make all the difference, and they wouldn’t have been possible without the Time Turner.
Why Did The Time Turner Change The Events In Prisoner Of Azkaban
When Harry, Ron and Hermione were first trying to complete their task “strange” things kept happening, such as being hit with rocks, saving Buckbeak howling to distract the transformed Prof. Lupin and casting a physical stag Patronus.
It was later revealed that these were in fact caused by their future selves via use of the Time Turner to try and change how events went down.
After using the time turner, the “present” Harry and Hermione were now the ones committing these acts. The same disruptions seemingly took place, yet the timeline somehow changed.
How is this possible?
It didn’t. The same events happens both times, but since the characters did not have first hand impressions of them all the first time, the reader is let to believe that the most obvious outcome happens, i.e. Buckbeak is executed instead of Harry and Hermione travelling back in time to be two places at the same time.
Nothing changes. You seem to be focussed on the execution of Buckbeak specifically, which I guess the movies portrayed badly? Here’s the passage from the book. As you can see, they aren’t actually around to see the execution.
Later we see this scene from the other side, including the swish and thud of the axe. The very fact that the action is described using the exact same words is a clear indication that this is the same event we heard first time round.
Why Was The Time Turner Never Used Again
It seems like it would be a very helpful device.
Why was it never used again, regardless of the purpose?
- b_jonasMay 18 ’12 at 19:46
- See also the same question on Movies & TV SE: movies.stackexchange.com/questions/124 Why does Harry only make use of time travel in The Prisoner of Azkaban?May 2 ’14 at 17:50
- 3In the original novels it was a Time Turnip, and I guess it just went off, or turnips were out of season.Jan 16 ’16 at 23:14
- 1Doesn’t seem duplicate of cited VTC reason, as that’s more specific to major events. This is more simply WHY wasn’t it used again at all.Jan 24 ’16 at 11:13
- My answer contains WoG information from Pottermore, if you like that better.
The Ministry regulates their control and usage, to stop people mucking about with them. When the Time-Turner is first introduced, Hermione tells us that
Professor McGonagall made me swear I wouldnt tell anyone. She had to write all sorts of letters to the Ministry of Magic so I could have one. She had to tell them that I was a model student, and that Id never, ever use it for anything except my studies.
Prisoner of Azkaban, chapter 21
From this, we can assume that the majority, if not all, Time Turners were under Ministry license and control. . Theyre obviously a subject of intense research in the Dept. of Mysteries, as we see in OotP. In the battle to escape, the Ministry stock is apparently destroyed:
So that explains why the Time Turner couldnt be used again, from a practical standpoint.
Harry Potter: 25 Things Wrong With Hermione Granger We All Choose To Ignore
Harry Potter may be the main character, but Hermione tends to get most of the focus from fans. Except where it counts.
In the Harry Potter series, we had the Golden Trio. These three characters made Harry Potter what it was and without them there would be no series. While Harry was the main protagonist, he didnt have all the attributes that would have enabled him to take down Voldemort. His friends also got separate personalities and abilities that made them stand out in their own ways. Rivaling Harry in the best character polls is Hermione Granger. A sizable portion of the fandom consider Hermione to be the best character in the series due to her multitude of capabilities as well as her mature personality.
Hermiones star was made brighter after Emma Watson portrayed her in the Harry Potter film series as she was quite a looker and was very close in personality to Hermione Granger. While Harry and Ron have some people who arent fans of them, Hermione never has anyone dislike her. Shes seen as the most complete of the trio due to her hardly ever showing tendencies that would make her unlikable. All in all, if youre a fan of Hermione, youre nothing special because of all the Harry Potter fandom feels the same way about her.
Here are 25 Things Wrong With Hermione Granger We All Choose To Ignore.
Where Did Hermione Get A Time Turner
You May Like: Is Lego Batman 3 Backwards Compatible
She Bosses Ron Around
Most of what we saw of Ron and Hermione during the Harry Potter novels was her bossing Ron around. Ron would generally be rather silly, but Hermione would mainly counter that by telling him what to do.
In times when they werent butting heads, Ron would follow whatever Hermione told him to do and their dynamic generally was just this. He never complained about it other than when he was annoyed by her. Looks like he didnt mind being the less dominant one in their relationship, so who are we to complain?
Why Did Hermione Even Need A Time
So we known that Bill, Percy and Barty Crouch Jr. all got 12 O.W.L.s meaning they took all the elective subjects offered in Year 3 and studied them till Year 5. Now Hermione also picked all elective subjects meaning she was studying 12 subjects in Year 3 like them.
Now J.K. Rowling revealed on Pottermore that the Time-Turner given to Hermione was the only one to “ever” enter Hogwarts. This means that Bill, Percy and Barty Jr. managed to to go through not only their 3rd year without needing one, but also their 4th and the much tougher fifth O.W.L year.
So like I said in the title, why did Hermione no one else has ever needed one in Hogwarts to study all 12 subjects. The 3 people mentioned to have gotten 12 O.W.L.s are probably not the only ones to do so all this time in Hogwarts.
Read Also: How Long Is Draco Malfoy’s Wand
She Gets Crazy Jealous
Fleur Delacour never did anything to Hermione she never even spoke to her, but Hermione vehemently hated Fleur for no reason. That is, unless you see how obviously she was jealous that Ron was into Fleur and ignored Hermione. Discounting Fleur, Hermione still got jealous when Ron was interested in Lavender and she was left in the cold.
We didnt see how Hermione was like in a relationship, but you can bet she wasnt the cool girlfriend guys hope they can find. Hermione seems to be very possessive of who shes interested in.
She Was Happy About Breaking Ron And Lavender Up
When Lavenders interest in Ron was a mere flirtation, Hermione didnt seem happy at all. And when Ron and Lavender became an item, Hermione was completely distraught about it. Once Hermione and Ron made up from their squabble, they started spending time together again and it was because of this Lavender dumped Ron.
Rather than feeling guilty, Hermione was seen with a visible smile on her face by Harry once Ron was single again. She was inwardly happy at what had happened because of her involvement.
Don’t Miss: What Is The Name Of Hermione’s Cat
Became The Minister Of Magic
This is the most fitting end to Hermione’s career. After all her hard work in and out of the Ministry, it makes total sense that she became the Minister of Magic. Hermione was elected the Minister for Magic, which clearly makes her the professional in the relationship. Sorry Ron. Ron seems to be interested in more of an entrepreneurial future, having become the co-manager Weasley’s Wizard Wheezes. During Harry Potter and The Cursed Child, Hermione is played by actress Noma Dumezweni, which sparked debate over Hermione’s race. Rowling shut down the conversation by saying that Hermione’s skin tone was never specified as white in the books. Some Witches and wizards might take issue with a black woman who is also a mudblood being the boss lady, but they clearly aren’t ready for 2018.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is a two-part play that initially began in London’s Palace Theatre. The story begins nineteen years after the events of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II. The play is currently on Broadway in New York and plans to eventually start performances in Melbourne, Australia in 2019. For those who can’t wait to see the play, there’s written copies available of the script, which reads just as easy as any other Harry Potter book.
Her Fear Of Voldemort
Hermione is a nerd who reads up on everything before she even has to deal with it. When shes introduced in Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone, Hermione already knows all about Voldemort and is shown to be as terrified of him as every other wizard.
This makes no sense, because she only has books to go from about Voldemort and was never raised to feat him like Ron. She was even terrified of saying his name until the fifth part. It doesnt make sense why a logical thinker like her would fear something such as a name.
Read Also: How To Put Clasp On Harry Potter Robe
In General Lawful Use Youre Only Not Supposed To See Yourself
The only restriction on her Ministry-sanctioned use of the Time-Turner would probably be that she couldnt see herself.
Wed only be seen by ourselves and Hagrid!
Harry, what do you think youd do if you saw yourself bursting into Hagrids house? said Hermione.
Id Id think Id gone mad, said Harry, or Id think there was some Dark Magic going on
Exactly! You wouldnt understand, you might even attack yourself! Dont you see? Professor McGonagall told me what awful things have happened when wizards have meddled with time loads of them ended up killing their past or future selves by mistake! – Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 21
However, it is possible that since shed know she had a Time-Turner before she started using it, shed be able to get around this because shed never see herself before shed be aware of having one, and therefore not surprised by seeing herself.
Harry Potter And The Half
New Potions professor Horace Slughorn invites Hermione to join his “Slug Club”, and she helps Ron retain his spot on the Gryffindor Quidditch team when she casts a confund spell on Cormac McLaggen, causing him to miss his last save attempt during Keeper tryouts. Hermione’s feelings for Ron continue to grow and she decides to make a move by inviting him to Slughorn’s Christmas Party, but he romances Lavender instead in retaliation for his belief that Hermione had kissed Krum years earlier. She attempts to get even by dating McLaggen at the Christmas party, but her plan goes awry and she abandons him midway through the party. Ron and Hermione continually feud with each other until he suffers a near-fatal poisoning from tainted mead, which frightens her enough to reconcile with him. Following Dumbledore’s death, Ron and Hermione both vow to stay by Harry’s side regardless of what happens. A minor subplot in the book is that Hermione and Harry form a rivalry in Potions, as Hermione is used to coming first in her subjects and is angered that Harry outperforms her undeservedly by following tips and different instructions written in the margins of Harry’s potions book by the previous owner. Hermione is also the only one of the trio to successfully pass her Apparition test .
You May Like: What Harry Potter House Am I In Test
Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows
Hermione later uses Polyjuice Potion to impersonate Bellatrix when the trio attempt to steal Hufflepuff’s cup from Gringotts. She, Harry, and Ron join Dumbledore’s Army in the Battle of Hogwarts, during which Hermione destroys Hufflepuff’s cup in the Chamber of Secrets with a basilisk fang, eliminating another Horcrux. Hermione and Ron also share their first kiss during the battle. In the final battle in the Great Hall, Hermione fights Bellatrix with the help of Ginny Weasley and Luna. However, the three of them are unable to defeat Bellatrix and stop fighting her once Molly Weasley orders them to disengage.
Epilogue and later life
Nineteen years after Voldemort’s death, Hermione and Ron have two children, Rose and Hugo. Though the epilogue does not explicitly say Hermione and Ron are married, news articles and other sources treat it as a fact. The two children are named Rose Granger-Weasley and Hugo Granger-Weasley.
Did Hermione Return The Time Turner
- d. Maybe Ron and Harry found a way to get us out, She thinks hopefully
- Potter Necklace jewelry.Time Turner Alloy-Hermione’s Necklace Jewelry With time Converter Hourglass for Women and Girls Decoration.Gold.Medium 4.1 out of 5 stars 84 $5.99 $ 5 . 99 $18.99 $18.9
- A Time-Turner may be used for short-term time travel. Hermione receives a Time-Turner from McGonagall in Prisoner of Azkaban, enabling her to attend more than one class simultaneously. Hermione is ordered to keep it a secret from everyone, including Harry and Ron, although they do notice the suspicious impossibility of her schedule and several.
Don’t Miss: How Did Dumbledore Get The Elder Wand
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix
Hermione becomes a Gryffindor prefect along with Ron and befriends Luna Lovegood, but their friendship gets off to a rocky start after Hermione chastises the publication of Luna’s father: “The Quibbler‘s rubbish, everyone knows that.” She also lambasts housemate Lavender Brown for believing the Daily Prophet‘s allegations of Harry fabricating stories of Voldemort’s return. Ron and Hermione spend much of their time bickering, likely due to their growing romantic feelings toward one another, but they show continued loyalty to Harry. One turning point in the series is when Hermione conceives the idea of Harry secretly teaching defensive magic to a small band of students in defiance of the Ministry of Magic‘s dictum to teach only the subject’s basic principles from a textbook, with no hands-on practice. Hermione gets an unexpectedly huge response, and the group becomes the nascent Dumbledore’s Army. She is involved in the battle in the Department of Mysteries and seriously injured by a spell from Death Eater Antonin Dolohov, but makes a full recovery.
Went Back To Hogwarts To Finish Her Seventh Year Of School
Hermione loves school, probably more than most and it’s natural to assume that after having to take part in the Second Wizarding War, Hermione felt the need to hit the books and feel a sense of normalcy. J.K Rowling confirmed that after the Deathly Hallows, Hermione returned to Hogwarts to complete her 7th year of school and took her N.E.W.T.s, also known as Nastily Exhausting Wizarding Tests. Getting good grades on your N.E.W.T.s is a requirement to getting a job at the Ministry of Magic, which also likely played a role in Hermione returning to school. We’d like to believe that after all those years of hard-work at Hogwarts that to simply not finish would be a tremendous let down for Hermione.
It would be awful for people to assume that her newfound celebrity was the reason behind her employment or rapid advancement within the Ministry. Hermione is the type of person who wants to earn what she gets and even though Harry became an Auror without completing his 7th year of school, Hermione would feel a bit tarnished by this fact. Harry has more practical experience than most when it comes to catching and tracking Death Eaters. After the Deathly Hallows, Kingsley Shacklebolt becomes the Minister of Magic and he was probably hard pressed to find Aurors he could trust. Plus, if you remember Dumbledore did tell Shacklebolt and Lupin that “Harry is the best hope we have. Trust him.” Dumbledore’s recommendation counts for a lot when it comes to job interviews.
Read Also: Where Can I Watch Harry Potter Movies Online